Exotropia and incomitant squint
This lesson covers the outward-turning eye, from the common intermittent exotropia of childhood to the constant exotropia that can signal a poorly seeing eye. It then turns to three congenital incomitant squints that examiners like because each has a single defining sign: Duane retraction syndrome, Brown syndrome and congenital fourth nerve palsy. It ends with the principles of treatment, including what recession and resection do.
The types of exotropia
An exotropia is a manifest outward deviation of one eye. A small latent tendency to drift out, an exophoria, is common in normal people and is held in check by fusion. Exotropia appears when fusion fails, either some of the time or all of the time.
| Type | Typical patient | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| Intermittent | Child, onset usually between infancy and 7 years | The commonest type. Eyes straight at times, one drifts out at others |
| Infantile (constant) | Onset in the first 6 months | Large constant angle that does not resolve. Associated with neurological and craniofacial disorders |
| Sensory | Older child or adult with one poorly seeing eye | The blind or weak eye drifts out |
| Consecutive | Previous esotropia | Usually follows surgical overcorrection of an esotropia |
| Convergence insufficiency | Older child or teenager | Deviation larger for near than distance, with symptoms on reading |
The direction in which a poorly seeing eye drifts depends on age. In a young infant it usually turns in. From about 2 to 4 years onwards, and in adults, it turns out. A constant exotropia of one eye is therefore treated as a sign of possible disease in that eye until a dilated examination shows otherwise, and NICE's Clinical Knowledge Summary lists constant unilateral exotropia among the squints that raise particular concern about an underlying cause.
Intermittent exotropia
In intermittent exotropia the child has normal binocular vision when the eyes are straight and suppresses one eye when it drifts. Because each eye is used normally much of the time, acuity is usually good in both eyes. The rate of refractive error is no higher than in other children.
The history is characteristic. The drift is seen when the child is tired, unwell or daydreaming, and when looking into the distance. It is also brought out by bright sunlight, when many children close one eye. The usual UK pattern is called intermittent distance exotropia: the eye drifts out for distance and the squint may disappear when the child looks at something near.
Clinically the deviation is measured for near and distance and sorted into types. In the basic type the two angles are within 10 prism dioptres of each other. In divergence excess the distance angle is larger by 10 prism dioptres or more. In convergence insufficiency the near angle is the larger.
What matters most for management is not the size of the angle but how well the child controls it. Control is good if the eye drifts only after the cover test and recovers at once, fair if it needs a blink or a refixation to recover, and poor if it drifts spontaneously and stays out. Scoring systems such as the Newcastle Control Score combine what the parents see at home with what is seen in clinic.
Many children are simply observed. A large American trial of children aged 3 to 10 with intermittent exotropia found that loss of stereopsis or progression to a constant squint over three years was uncommon. Options for those who need treatment are listed below.
- Correct any refractive error, especially myopia and astigmatism, since a clear image helps fusion.
- Over-minus lenses: glasses with extra minus power make the child accommodate, and the linked convergence helps to pull the eye in. The effect may be temporary.
- Part-time patching and, for convergence insufficiency, convergence exercises.
- Surgery when control is deteriorating, the eye is out for much of the day, or stereopsis is being lost. The usual operations are recession of both lateral rectus muscles, or recession of one lateral rectus with resection of the medial rectus of the same eye.
Incomitant squint and Duane retraction syndrome
An incomitant squint changes with the direction of gaze because one muscle cannot do its job, either through weakness or because it is tethered. An acquired incomitant squint in a child is a neurological problem until proved otherwise. The three conditions that follow are different: they are present from birth, stable, and recognisable from a single sign.
Duane retraction syndrome is a miswiring of the eye muscles. The motor neurones of the sixth nerve fail to develop, so the lateral rectus has no normal nerve supply. A branch of the third nerve, which should supply only the medial rectus, grows into the lateral rectus as well. Two things follow. The eye cannot abduct, because the lateral rectus receives no signal when the brain asks for abduction. And when the brain asks for adduction, the signal goes to the medial and lateral rectus together, so the two muscles contract against each other and pull the globe back into the orbit.
That gives the defining sign: on adduction the globe retracts and the lid opening (palpebral fissure) narrows. The eye may also shoot up or down as it adducts. Duane syndrome is one of the congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders.
| Type | Share of cases | Main limitation | Usual position looking straight ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 75 to 80% | Abduction | Esotropia |
| 2 | 5 to 10% | Adduction | Exotropia |
| 3 | 10 to 20% | Both | Either |
It is usually unilateral and sporadic, affects the left eye more often than the right, and is somewhat more common in girls. About 30% of cases are part of a wider syndrome, such as Okihiro syndrome with abnormalities of the radius and thumb (caused by variants in SALL4), Goldenhar syndrome and Wildervanck syndrome, so hearing and the hands and spine are checked.
Children with Duane syndrome find a head position in which the eyes are aligned, typically a face turn towards the affected side in type 1, and use it to keep binocular vision. Because of this, acuity is usually normal and amblyopia occurs in only about 10%. Most need no treatment beyond glasses if required. Surgery cannot restore the missing movement. It is offered for a marked head turn, a significant squint in the straight-ahead position or severe retraction.
Brown syndrome
The superior oblique muscle runs forwards along the upper inner wall of the orbit, and its tendon passes through a pulley, the trochlea, before turning back to attach to the top of the globe behind its equator. When the eye looks up and in, the back of the globe moves down, and the tendon must slide freely through the trochlea to let it.
In Brown syndrome the tendon cannot slide, because it is short, thickened or stuck at the trochlea. The eye is tethered, and the result is limited elevation of the eye in adduction. Elevation in abduction is normal or nearly so. Looking straight ahead the eyes are usually aligned, though severe cases have a downward deviation of the affected eye and a chin-up head posture. The eye may dip down as it adducts, and some patients feel or hear a click.
3D atlasThe superior oblique tendon must slide through the trochlea for the eye to look up and in. In Brown syndrome it cannot.Because the problem is mechanical, the forced duction test is positive: under anaesthesia the surgeon cannot push the eye up and in with forceps. This separates Brown syndrome from weakness of the inferior oblique, in which the eye moves freely when pushed. Cases are congenital or acquired. Acquired cases follow trauma, surgery or inflammation around the trochlea, for example in juvenile idiopathic arthritis.
Most congenital cases are simply observed, and spontaneous improvement over the years is common. Surgery to lengthen the tendon is reserved for a deviation in the straight-ahead position or a significant head posture.
Congenital fourth nerve palsy
The fourth (trochlear) nerve supplies the superior oblique, which pulls the eye down, most of all when the eye is turned in, and rotates the top of the eye towards the nose (intorsion). When the muscle is weak the affected eye sits higher than the other, a hypertropia, and is rotated outwards. Its antagonist, the inferior oblique, is unopposed, so the eye shoots up when it looks in towards the nose.
The vertical deviation follows a fixed pattern. It is worse when the patient looks to the opposite side and worse when the head is tilted towards the affected side. These two findings, added to the first step of identifying which eye is higher, make up the Parks three-step test. The third step is the Bielschowsky head tilt test. A right hypertropia that increases on left gaze and on right head tilt is a right superior oblique palsy.
The child discovers that the deviation is least with the head tilted the other way, and so presents with a head tilt away from the affected side, often with the chin down. A child referred with a wry neck (torticollis) may have nothing wrong with the neck: the tilt disappears when one eye is covered. Old family photographs often show the same tilt going back years.
Fourth nerve palsy is a common congenital cranial nerve palsy. Children with it develop a very large capacity to fuse vertical misalignment, so they can control a hypertropia of more than 10 prism dioptres with little or no double vision. In adult life that control can fail, with illness, age or stress, and the patient presents with apparently new vertical diplopia. A long-standing head tilt in old photographs and a large vertical fusion range point to a decompensated congenital palsy and not to a new neurological event. Treatment, when the deviation causes symptoms, is with prisms or surgery on the muscles that move the eye vertically.
Principles of treatment
Squint management has four aims: exclude serious disease, get the best acuity in each eye, restore binocular vision where possible, and straighten the eyes. The tools are used in a set order.
Glasses come first. They sharpen the image, which helps fusion, and in accommodative esotropia they are the whole treatment. Amblyopia treatment follows. Botulinum toxin injected into an eye muscle blocks the release of acetylcholine at the neuromuscular junction and paralyses the muscle temporarily. The effect begins after a few days, peaks at 1 to 2 weeks and lasts up to about 3 months. Its uses include some childhood squints, where it is given under general anaesthetic, preventing the medial rectus from tightening in a sixth nerve palsy, and eyes that are still misaligned after several operations.
Surgery changes the pull of a muscle by altering its length or its point of attachment.
| Recession | Resection | |
|---|---|---|
| What is done | The muscle is detached and re-attached further back on the globe | A length of muscle is removed and the muscle re-attached at its original insertion |
| Effect | Slackens the muscle and weakens its action | Tightens the muscle and strengthens its action |
| For esotropia | Medial rectus | Lateral rectus |
| For exotropia | Lateral rectus | Medial rectus |
A horizontal squint can be corrected by recessing the same muscle in both eyes or by a recession and a resection on one eye. Parents should know three things: surgery straightens the eyes but does not improve acuity, glasses are usually still needed afterwards, and more than one operation is sometimes required.
Summary
- Intermittent exotropia is the commonest exotropia, appears when the child is tired or looking into the distance, and often makes the child close one eye in sunlight.
- Management of intermittent exotropia depends on how well it is controlled, and many children are observed.
- A constant exotropia of one eye can be sensory, so the eye must be examined for a cause of poor vision.
- Duane syndrome is a congenital miswiring in which the lateral rectus is supplied by the third nerve, giving limited abduction with globe retraction and lid fissure narrowing on adduction.
- Duane type 1, with limited abduction, makes up about three quarters of cases.
- Brown syndrome is limited elevation in adduction caused by a superior oblique tendon that cannot slide through the trochlea, with a positive forced duction test.
- Congenital fourth nerve palsy gives a hypertropia that is worse on opposite gaze and on tilting the head to the same side, with a compensatory head tilt away from the affected side.
- Botulinum toxin paralyses a muscle for up to about 3 months.
- Recession weakens a muscle by moving its insertion back, and resection strengthens a muscle by shortening it.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.