Skip to content
Pass Duke Elder
Textbook / Chapter 11 / Strabismus and paediatric ophthalmology

Esotropia

Esotropia, an inward-turning eye, is the squint seen most often in babies and young children. A handful of types account for nearly all cases, and they are told apart by the age of onset, the refraction and whether the eye can abduct. This lesson covers pseudosquint, infantile esotropia, accommodative esotropia in its full and partial forms, and the sixth nerve palsy that must not be missed.

10 minute read7 linked questions

Sorting out an inward turn

The previous lesson showed how to prove that an eye is turned in. The next step is to decide which kind of esotropia it is, because the treatments differ completely: one type needs only reassurance, one needs glasses, one needs surgery and one needs a brain scan. Four questions do most of the work.

  1. Is it a true squint? Symmetrical corneal reflexes and no movement on the cover test mean a pseudosquint.
  2. When did it start? Before 6 months suggests infantile esotropia. Between about 1 and 5 years suggests accommodative esotropia.
  3. What is the cycloplegic refraction, and what happens to the squint in full glasses?
  4. Can each eye abduct fully? If not, the squint is incomitant and a sixth nerve palsy or Duane syndrome must be considered.
InfantileFully accommodativePartially accommodativeSixth nerve palsy
OnsetFirst 6 monthsUsually 2 to 4 yearsUsually 2 to 4 yearsAny age, acquired
AngleLarge and constantVariable, often intermittent at firstVariableBigger for distance and on looking to the affected side
RefractionUsually no significant errorHypermetropia, often around +4.00HypermetropiaNot relevant
Effect of glassesNoneEyes become straightAngle shrinks but a squint remainsNone
AbductionFull, though hidden by cross-fixationFullFullLimited
Main treatmentSurgeryGlasses aloneGlasses, then surgery for the remainderFind and treat the cause
The main childhood esotropias compared

Pseudosquint

A pseudosquint is the appearance of a squint when the eyes are in fact straight. The usual reason in a baby is a broad, flat nasal bridge with prominent epicanthic folds, the folds of skin that run down from the upper lid over the inner corner of the eye. They cover the white of the eye on the nasal side, so each eye looks closer to the nose than it is, most of all when the child looks to the side. A narrow distance between the pupils has the same effect.

The diagnosis rests on two findings: the corneal light reflexes are symmetrical, and nothing moves on the cover test. The folds become less obvious as the face grows, usually by 2 to 3 years of age.

Infantile esotropia

Infantile esotropia is a constant esotropia that begins in the first 6 months of life. It is often called congenital esotropia, but it is rarely present at birth. Brief, variable misalignment is normal in the first 3 months, so the diagnosis is made when a large, steady inward turn persists beyond that. The cause is not known, and most affected children are otherwise healthy.

The features are distinctive.

  • The angle is large, typically 30 prism dioptres or more, constant and comitant.
  • The refraction is usually normal for age, so glasses do not help. Hypermetropia of +2.00 or more is still corrected as a trial to exclude an accommodative element.
  • Cross-fixation: because both eyes are turned in, the child uses the right eye to look to the left and the left eye to look to the right, and has no need to abduct either. This can look like a bilateral sixth nerve palsy. Abduction is shown to be full by covering one eye or by turning the child's head (the doll's head manoeuvre).
  • A child who cross-fixates uses both eyes and may not become amblyopic, but overall amblyopia develops in about 40 to 50% of children with infantile esotropia.

Three associated signs appear later, usually after the first birthday, and are favourite exam facts. Inferior oblique overaction makes the eye shoot upwards when it looks in towards the nose. Dissociated vertical deviation is a slow upward drift of whichever eye is covered or not being attended to. Latent nystagmus is a horizontal jerk nystagmus that appears only when one eye is covered, with the fast phase beating towards the uncovered eye.

Treatment is surgical, after any amblyopia and refractive error have been addressed. The standard operation is recession of both medial rectus muscles, which weakens the two muscles that pull the eyes in. Botulinum toxin injected into the medial recti is an alternative in some units. The aim is to straighten the eyes early enough for some binocular vision to develop. Many surgeons operate before the age of 2 years, on evidence that earlier alignment gives better binocular results, although the best timing is still debated.

Expectations need to be realistic. Normal high-grade stereopsis is rarely achieved. A good result is alignment to within about 10 prism dioptres with peripheral fusion and a small central suppression area in one eye, a state called monofixation syndrome. A further operation is needed in roughly 15 to 30% of children.

3D atlasThe medial rectus adducts the eye and the lateral rectus abducts it. Esotropia surgery weakens the medial rectus, strengthens the lateral rectus, or both.

Accommodative esotropia

This is the type to understand thoroughly, because its mechanism explains its treatment. A hypermetropic (long-sighted) eye is too weak optically for its length, so the image falls behind the retina unless the lens accommodates. A hypermetropic child can see clearly, but only by accommodating all the time, and more still for near. Accommodation and convergence are linked through the near reflex, so every dioptre of accommodation brings some convergence with it. If the child's ability to diverge the eyes back out (fusional divergence) cannot cancel that extra convergence, the eyes turn in. The result is an accommodative esotropia.

It typically appears between 2 and 4 years, the age at which children start to look hard at small near objects, though it can start as early as 6 months. The eyes were straight in infancy. At first the turn is intermittent, seen when the child is tired or concentrating on something close, and over time it becomes constant. The hypermetropia is usually at least +2.00 and averages about +4.00.

There are three patterns.

  • Fully accommodative (refractive) esotropia. The whole squint is driven by uncorrected hypermetropia. With the full cycloplegic correction in glasses the eyes are straight for distance and near, and binocular vision is present. The AC/A ratio is normal.
  • Partially accommodative esotropia. Glasses reduce the angle but do not abolish it. Part of the squint is accommodative and part is not.
  • High AC/A ratio (convergence excess) esotropia. The child converges too much for each dioptre of accommodation. The eyes are straight or nearly straight for distance but turn in for near, with a near angle at least 10 prism dioptres larger than the distance angle. This can occur with any refractive error.

Treatment starts with the full hypermetropic correction found at cycloplegic refraction, worn all the time. The glasses do the focusing, the child stops accommodating, the drive to converge goes, and the eyes straighten. Glasses alone control the squint in about two thirds of children. Parents need to understand the point made in NICE's Clinical Knowledge Summary: many of these children see perfectly well without glasses, and the glasses are there to straighten the eyes, not to sharpen the vision. The squint returns when the glasses come off, and that is expected.

For a high AC/A ratio, bifocals add extra plus power in the lower segment so that near work needs no accommodation. Amblyopia is treated alongside. Surgery is reserved for the part of the squint that remains in full glasses, that is, for partially accommodative esotropia, and only that residual angle is operated on. Operating on a fully accommodative esotropia is a classic error: with the glasses on, the child would then be overcorrected into an exotropia.

Sixth nerve palsy and other worrying esotropias

The sixth (abducens) cranial nerve supplies the lateral rectus, the muscle that abducts the eye. When it fails, the medial rectus is unopposed and the eye turns in. Unlike the squints above, this esotropia is incomitant: it is larger for distance than for near, and larger still on looking towards the affected side, where the eye cannot abduct. A child old enough to describe it has horizontal double vision. Many children turn the face towards the affected side, which keeps both eyes pointing away from the weak muscle's field so that they can stay aligned.

The causes are the reason for urgency. In children, tumours and trauma are the leading causes. Brainstem glioma and other posterior fossa tumours involve the nerve directly, and raised intracranial pressure from any cause can stretch the nerve, producing a sixth nerve palsy as a false localising sign. A benign palsy can follow a viral illness, but that is a diagnosis made after imaging. NICE advises that a child with a paralytic squint is referred urgently for neurological assessment, and that a new squint with headache, vomiting or ataxia is referred immediately to acute paediatric services.

Two conditions mimic it. Infantile esotropia with cross-fixation appears to lack abduction until each eye is tested alone. Duane syndrome, covered in the next lesson, has limited abduction from birth, but the eye retracts and the lid opening narrows on adduction, and the child is otherwise well.

NICE's Clinical Knowledge Summary also flags a sudden esotropia starting after the age of 3 to 4 years, particularly without a family history or significant hypermetropia, as a pattern that raises concern about an underlying cause. Finally, any eye that sees poorly in infancy tends to turn in (a sensory esotropia), which is one more reason why every esotropia gets a dilated fundus examination.

Putting the management in order

Whatever the type, the sequence is the same. First exclude a serious cause by checking abduction, the red reflex and the fundus. Then refract under cycloplegia and prescribe the full hypermetropic correction. Then treat amblyopia, with patching or atropine as described in the first lesson of this chapter. Only then is surgery considered, for the deviation that remains. Surgery straightens the eyes. It does not improve acuity, and it does not replace glasses in a child whose squint is accommodative. The principles of squint surgery, recession and resection, are explained in the next lesson.

Summary

  • Pseudosquint from epicanthic folds shows symmetrical corneal reflexes and no movement on the cover test.
  • Infantile esotropia starts in the first 6 months as a large constant angle without significant refractive error.
  • Cross-fixation in infantile esotropia can mimic bilateral sixth nerve palsy until each eye is tested separately.
  • Infantile esotropia is associated with inferior oblique overaction, dissociated vertical deviation and latent nystagmus, and is treated by surgery such as bilateral medial rectus recession.
  • Accommodative esotropia arises because a hypermetropic child must accommodate to see clearly, and accommodation drives convergence.
  • Fully accommodative esotropia is completely corrected by full cycloplegic glasses and needs no surgery.
  • Partially accommodative esotropia leaves a residual angle in glasses, and only that residual angle is operated on.
  • A high AC/A ratio gives an esotropia that is worse for near and can be helped by bifocals.
  • Sixth nerve palsy gives an incomitant esotropia with limited abduction, worse for distance, and in a child needs urgent neurological assessment.

Check yourself

Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.

1. A 3-year-old has an esotropia and a cycloplegic refraction of +5.00 in each eye. What is the first step in treatment?
2. Which feature is typical of infantile esotropia?
3. An esotropia that is larger for distance than for near, with limited abduction of the right eye, suggests:
4. Pseudosquint in an infant is most often caused by:
Practise 7 questions on this lesson

Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.