Proptosis and orbital tumours
The orbit is a rigid box, so almost anything that grows inside it announces itself by pushing the eye out of place. This lesson gives a method for working out the cause of proptosis from its direction, speed and behaviour and from the patient's age, then describes the orbital masses of adults and of children that the exam expects you to recognise.
Measuring proptosis
Proptosis is forward displacement of the globe. Exophthalmos means the same thing and is often reserved for thyroid eye disease. The orbit is a bony cone open only at the front, so any increase in the volume of its contents moves the eye forwards, and anything that reduces the contents or enlarges the cone lets the eye sink back (enophthalmos).
Proptosis is measured with an exophthalmometer (the Hertel instrument is the usual one), which rests on the bony lateral orbital rims and reads the distance from the rim to the apex of the cornea. Normal readings are roughly 12 to 21 mm and vary with sex and ethnic origin, so the comparison between the two eyes is more useful than the absolute figure: a difference of more than 2 mm is abnormal.
Pseudoproptosis is an eye that looks prominent without being displaced. The causes are a large globe, as in high myopia, a retracted upper lid, and enophthalmos of the other eye.
A method: direction, speed, behaviour, age
Four questions narrow the cause before any scan.
Is it axial? The four rectus muscles form a cone behind the eye, with the optic nerve running down its centre. A mass inside the cone (intraconal) pushes the eye straight forwards: axial proptosis. The usual intraconal lesions are a cavernous venous malformation and tumours of the optic nerve, and thyroid eye disease is also axial because the muscles themselves enlarge. A mass outside the cone pushes the eye away from itself as well as forwards. A lacrimal gland tumour, in the upper outer corner, displaces the eye down and in. A mass arising from a sinus pushes the eye away from that sinus.
How fast? Hours suggests haemorrhage. Days suggests infection, inflammation or, in a child, rhabdomyosarcoma. Weeks to months suggests malignancy or thyroid eye disease. Years suggests a benign tumour.
Does it change? Proptosis that pulsates in time with the heartbeat, with a bruit, is an arteriovenous communication such as a carotid-cavernous fistula. Pulsation without a bruit occurs when brain pulsation is transmitted through a defect in the orbital roof or sphenoid wing, as can happen in neurofibromatosis type 1. Proptosis that appears on straining, coughing or bending forward is an orbital varix, a distensible vein that fills when venous pressure rises.
How old is the patient? In adults thyroid eye disease is the commonest cause of both bilateral and unilateral proptosis, followed by lymphoma and idiopathic inflammation. In children infection is the first thing to exclude, and the tumours are different from those of adults.
| Finding | Think of |
|---|---|
| Bilateral with lid retraction | Thyroid eye disease |
| Slow painless axial proptosis in a middle-aged adult | Cavernous venous malformation |
| Eye pushed down and in, slowly, without pain | Pleomorphic adenoma of the lacrimal gland |
| Eye pushed down and in, quickly, with pain | Adenoid cystic carcinoma of the lacrimal gland |
| Pulsatile with a bruit and red eye | Carotid-cavernous fistula |
| Appears on Valsalva | Orbital varix |
| Enophthalmos in a woman with a history of breast cancer | Scirrhous breast metastasis |
| Rapid proptosis over weeks in a child | Rhabdomyosarcoma |
Every patient with proptosis needs acuity, colour vision, pupils, eye movements and the optic disc checked, then imaging: CT shows bone best and MRI soft tissue.
Adult tumours: vascular, lymphoid and lacrimal
Cavernous venous malformation, formerly called cavernous haemangioma, is the commonest benign orbital tumour of adults. It is a well-defined, encapsulated mass of large blood-filled channels with very slow flow, usually inside the muscle cone. The typical patient is a middle-aged woman with painless axial proptosis developing over months to years. Pressure on the back of the globe shortens the eye, causing a hyperopic shift, and wrinkles the choroid, giving choroidal folds on fundoscopy. Small symptomless lesions are watched. Those threatening vision or causing diplopia are excised.
Orbital lymphoma is among the commonest orbital malignancies in adults and affects the middle-aged and elderly. Most are low-grade B cell lymphomas of the extranodal marginal zone (MALT) type. The presentation is a slowly progressive, painless mass, often in the lacrimal gland or under the conjunctiva, where it shows as a salmon-pink patch. On imaging it moulds itself around the globe and bone without destroying them. Diagnosis needs a biopsy, and every patient is staged for systemic disease. Localised disease is treated with radiotherapy.
Lacrimal gland masses lie in the upper outer orbit. Most are inflammatory or lymphoid. Of the epithelial tumours, roughly half are benign and half malignant, and the two that matter are opposites.
| Pleomorphic adenoma | Adenoid cystic carcinoma | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Benign mixed tumour | Malignant |
| History | Long, often a year or more | Short, a few months |
| Pain | Painless | Painful, from invasion of nerves and bone |
| Imaging | Well-defined round mass | Infiltrating mass, bone destruction |
| Biopsy | Avoid incisional biopsy; excise whole with capsule intact | Biopsy to confirm |
| Outlook | Excellent if removed intact; recurrence and malignant change if the capsule is breached | Poor; perineural spread and distant metastasis |
Adult tumours: the optic nerve and metastases
Optic nerve sheath meningioma arises from the meningeal cells of the arachnoid around the nerve. It affects middle-aged adults, women about three times as often as men, and is associated with neurofibromatosis type 2 when it occurs in the young. It strangles the nerve slowly. The classic triad is painless progressive visual loss, optic atrophy and optociliary shunt vessels: collateral veins on the disc that divert retinal venous blood to the choroid when the central retinal vein is compressed. The full triad is present in only a minority. MRI shows the enhancing sheath on either side of the darker nerve, the tram-track sign. Surgery usually blinds the eye, because tumour and nerve share the pial blood supply, so progressive cases are treated with fractionated radiotherapy.
Metastases to the orbit in adults come most often from the breast, and may appear before the primary is known. They favour the fat and muscles, so diplopia and restricted movement are prominent. Scirrhous breast carcinoma can contract the orbital tissues and pull the eye backwards, causing enophthalmos, a useful exception to the rule that orbital tumours cause proptosis. In children, metastatic neuroblastoma is the classic orbital secondary.
Orbital masses in children
Capillary (infantile) haemangioma is a benign tumour of proliferating blood vessels and a common lid and orbital tumour of infancy, about three times commoner in girls. It follows a set timetable: it appears in the first weeks of life, grows during the first year, then slowly involutes, with most resolved by about eight years of age. A superficial lesion is a raised bright red strawberry mark that blanches on pressure. A deeper one is a bluish swelling that enlarges when the baby cries.
The lesion itself is harmless. The threat is amblyopia, usually from astigmatism caused by the mass pressing on the cornea, and less often from the lid covering the pupil. Treatment is therefore given when vision is threatened. Oral propranolol is first line and is started under specialist supervision. The BNF for Children dose is 1 mg/kg daily in three divided doses at first, increased to a usual maintenance of 2 mg/kg daily in divided doses. Bradycardia, hypotension, bronchospasm and hypoglycaemia are the risks, and treatment is interrupted if the child is not feeding. Refractive correction and occlusion treat the amblyopia.
A dermoid cyst is a choristoma: normal tissue in the wrong place. Skin elements are trapped along a bony suture as the skull bones fuse, most often at the frontozygomatic suture, giving a smooth, firm, painless lump at the outer end of the eyebrow in a young child. The wall is keratinised squamous epithelium with hair follicles and sebaceous glands, and the cavity holds keratin and hair. Leakage of the contents provokes granulomatous inflammation, so the cyst is excised intact. Deep cysts present later with proptosis and are imaged before surgery.
Rhabdomyosarcoma is the commonest primary orbital malignancy of childhood, with a mean age of about seven. It arises from primitive mesenchymal cells able to form striated muscle, not from the extraocular muscles. Proptosis develops rapidly over weeks, typically with the eye pushed down and out by a mass in the upper inner orbit, and the lid may be red and swollen enough to suggest cellulitis, but the child is well and afebrile. The embryonal type is the commonest and has the better outlook, and the alveolar type the worst. Urgent imaging and biopsy are followed by chemotherapy and radiotherapy, which have raised survival from about 30% to over 90%.
Optic nerve glioma is a low-grade pilocytic astrocytoma of the optic nerve, presenting in the first decade with gradual visual loss and proptosis. About 30% occur in children with neurofibromatosis type 1, and about 15% of children with that condition develop one. MRI shows fusiform enlargement and kinking of the nerve. Many are simply observed because they grow slowly or stop.
Carotid-cavernous fistula
A carotid-cavernous fistula is an abnormal connection between the carotid arterial system and the cavernous sinus, the venous lake beside the pituitary through which the internal carotid artery runs. Arterial blood enters the sinus and flows backwards into the veins that drain the orbit, so the signs are those of venous congestion at arterial pressure.
A direct fistula is a tear in the internal carotid artery itself. It is high flow and usually follows head injury, or less often a ruptured aneurysm. It presents abruptly with the triad of pulsatile proptosis, a bruit and chemosis. An indirect (dural) fistula is fed by small meningeal branches. It is low flow, arises spontaneously, typically in older women with hypertension, and presents insidiously as a chronic red eye that is often treated as conjunctivitis for months.
The eye signs are the same in kind. The episcleral veins become dilated, tortuous and bright red, running in corkscrews up to the limbus. Intraocular pressure rises because aqueous has to drain into episcleral veins that are now at high pressure. The retinal veins dilate. Ophthalmoplegia is common, from swollen muscles or from nerve palsy in the cavernous sinus, the sixth nerve especially. Scans show a dilated superior ophthalmic vein, and catheter angiography confirms the diagnosis. Direct fistulas are closed by endovascular embolisation. Many dural fistulas close spontaneously and mild ones are observed.
Summary
- A difference of more than 2 mm between the eyes on exophthalmometry is abnormal.
- Intraconal masses cause axial proptosis; extraconal masses push the eye away from the mass.
- Thyroid eye disease is the commonest cause of both unilateral and bilateral proptosis in adults.
- Pulsatile proptosis with a bruit is a carotid-cavernous fistula; proptosis on Valsalva is a varix.
- Cavernous venous malformation is the commonest benign orbital tumour in adults: slow, painless, axial and intraconal.
- Orbital lymphoma is usually a low-grade MALT lymphoma, painless, with a salmon patch, moulding around structures.
- Pleomorphic adenoma of the lacrimal gland is painless and excised intact without prior biopsy; adenoid cystic carcinoma is painful.
- Optic nerve sheath meningioma gives visual loss, optic atrophy and optociliary shunt vessels; optic nerve glioma is linked to neurofibromatosis type 1.
- Capillary haemangioma grows in the first year then involutes; it is treated with oral propranolol when it threatens vision.
- Rhabdomyosarcoma is the commonest primary orbital malignancy in children and causes rapid proptosis that mimics cellulitis.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.