Skip to content
Pass Duke Elder
Textbook / Chapter 12 / Orbit, eyelids, lacrimal system and oculoplastics

The watery eye and lacrimal drainage surgery

A watery eye is either making too many tears or failing to drain them, and the two need opposite treatments. This lesson follows a tear from the gland to the nose, shows how simple clinic tests locate a blockage, and covers infection of the drainage system and the operation that bypasses a blocked tear duct.

10 minute read4 linked questions

From gland to nose

Tears are made by the lacrimal gland in the upper outer orbit and by small accessory glands in the conjunctiva. They spread across the eye with each blink, and some evaporate. The rest collect as a strip along the lower lid margin, the tear meniscus, and drain at the inner corner of the eye.

The drainage pathway is a tube some 35 mm long. It begins at the two puncta, the small openings at the inner end of the upper and lower lid margins, which normally face backwards into the tear lake. Each leads into a canaliculus, which runs a short way vertically and then turns to run horizontally towards the nose. The two usually join as the common canaliculus and enter the lacrimal sac, which lies in a bony hollow, the lacrimal fossa, behind the medial canthal tendon. The sac continues downwards as the nasolacrimal duct, which runs through bone to open into the nose under the inferior turbinate, in the inferior meatus. A fold of mucosa at this lower opening is the valve of Hasner, the site of the blockage in congenital obstruction.

Tears do not simply fall down this tube. They are pumped. The orbicularis muscle is attached around the canaliculi and sac, so each blink squeezes tears along and each relaxation draws more in. This lacrimal pump explains why a facial nerve palsy causes a watery eye even though every tube is open: the lids neither blink nor hold the punctum against the globe.

Two kinds of watery eye

Epiphora strictly means tears spilling over the lid onto the cheek. The first step is to decide which of two mechanisms is at work.

Overproduction (hyperlacrimation, or reflex tearing) is a normal gland responding to an irritated eye. The trigger may be an inturned lash, a foreign body or corneal disease. The commonest and least intuitive trigger is dry eye and blepharitis: an unstable tear film lets the cornea dry between blinks, the exposed surface stings, and the lacrimal gland floods the eye in reply. These patients complain of watering that comes in bursts, in wind or cold or while reading, with a gritty or burning eye in between. The treatment is lubricants and lid hygiene, and surgery on the tear ducts will not help.

Impaired drainage is failure of outflow. It may be a failure of the pump, a punctum that is out of position or too narrow, or a blockage of the canaliculi, sac or duct. The watering is more constant, and tears run down the cheek. Acquired blockage of the nasolacrimal duct is the commonest structural cause. It usually arises from chronic low-grade inflammation and scarring of the duct lining, and is seen most in older women, who have a narrower duct.

Overproduction (reflex tearing)Impaired drainage
PatternIntermittent, in burstsConstant, tears overflow onto the cheek
Other symptomsGrittiness, burning, rednessStickiness, mucus at the inner corner, little discomfort
Lids and surfaceBlepharitis, poor tear film, trichiasis, entropionEctropion, punctal stenosis, lax lid, or normal
Dye disappearanceDye clearsDye retained
SyringingPasses freely to the throatRegurgitates
TreatmentTreat the ocular surface or lid causeCorrect lid or punctum, or bypass the blockage
Overproduction and impaired drainage compared

Examining and testing the drainage system

Examination starts with the lids: laxity, ectropion, entropion, misdirected lashes and the strength of the blink. The puncta are inspected for position and size. The area below the medial canthus is pressed to see whether mucus or pus refluxes from the puncta, which indicates a distended sac above a blocked duct. The tear film and cornea are examined with fluorescein.

The fluorescein dye disappearance test is the simplest functional test. A drop of fluorescein is placed in each lower fornix and the tear meniscus is viewed with the blue light after five minutes. Dye that has gone means drainage works. Dye that remains means drainage is impaired somewhere between the punctum and the nose. Comparing the two eyes is helpful when only one waters.

Probing and syringing locates a blockage. After a drop of topical anaesthetic the punctum is dilated, a fine blunt cannula is passed along the lower canaliculus, and saline is injected. Two pieces of information come from this: what the cannula feels, and where the saline goes.

  • Hard stop: the cannula passes all the way to the sac and touches the bone of the lacrimal fossa. The canaliculus is open.
  • Soft stop: the cannula meets a spongy resistance before reaching bone and the lid is dragged with it. The canaliculus or common canaliculus is blocked.
  • Saline reaches the nose or throat and the patient tastes it: the system is anatomically open, although a narrowed duct or a failed pump can still cause watering.
  • Saline comes back through the same punctum: blockage of that canaliculus.
  • Clear saline comes back through the opposite punctum: blockage at the common canaliculus.
  • Saline mixed with mucus comes back through the opposite punctum, after the sac has filled: blockage of the nasolacrimal duct.

The older Jones dye tests asked the same question in two stages, first whether fluorescein placed in the eye reaches the nose unaided, and then whether it can be washed through by syringing. Few clinicians use them now. Contrast X-ray of the ducts (dacryocystography) and a nuclear medicine scan (lacrimal scintigraphy) are reserved for cases that remain unclear.

Problems at the punctum and canaliculus

A punctum can be in the wrong place or too small. In early lower lid ectropion the punctum lifts away from the tear lake before the rest of the lid turns out, and it is repositioned by tightening the lid or by a small operation on the inner surface of the lid that turns it back in. Punctal stenosis is narrowing of the opening, seen with age, chronic blepharitis and some topical and systemic drugs. It is treated by dilation or by punctoplasty, in which the opening is enlarged with a small snip.

Canalicular blockage follows trauma, infection, some chemotherapy drugs and previous punctal plugs. It is the hardest part of the system to reconstruct. When the canaliculi cannot be reopened the whole pathway is bypassed with a Lester Jones tube: a small glass tube placed from the inner corner of the eye through a bony opening into the nose, an operation called conjunctivodacryocystorhinostomy.

Canaliculitis is a chronic infection of a canaliculus, classically with Actinomyces israelii, an anaerobic, filamentous, Gram-positive bacterium. The organism forms gritty yellow concretions (sulphur granules) that sit in the canaliculus where drops cannot reach them. The patient has a watery, sticky, red eye on one side that has been treated repeatedly as conjunctivitis without success. The signs are at the inner end of one lid: a red, swollen, pouting punctum, and discharge with granules expressed on pressing the canaliculus. Topical antibiotics alone rarely cure it. The treatment is canaliculotomy, opening the canaliculus and scraping out the concretions.

Dacryocystitis

Dacryocystitis is infection of the lacrimal sac. It is nearly always secondary to a blocked nasolacrimal duct: tears and mucus stagnate in the sac and become infected. It occurs in infants with congenital obstruction and in adults over 40, mainly women.

Acute dacryocystitis comes on over hours to days with a painful, red, tense swelling at the inner corner of the eye, just below the medial canthal tendon, and pus may be expressed from the puncta. Staphylococci and streptococci are the usual organisms. Infection can spread into the lid as a preseptal cellulitis or, uncommonly, into the orbit, and an abscess may point and discharge through the skin, leaving a fistula. Treatment is a systemic antibiotic and warm compresses, with intravenous treatment if there is orbital involvement. The ducts should not be probed while the infection is acute, because the instrument can create a false passage.

Chronic dacryocystitis is a persistently watery, sticky eye with recurrent mild conjunctivitis. The sac may distend with mucus to form a mucocele, a painless swelling below the medial canthal tendon that empties through the puncta when pressed. A lump that extends above the tendon is not typical of a mucocele and should be imaged to exclude a tumour of the sac. Antibiotics settle the infection but not the cause, so once an attack has resolved the definitive treatment in an adult is dacryocystorhinostomy.

Dacryocystorhinostomy

Dacryocystorhinostomy (DCR) bypasses a blocked nasolacrimal duct. The surgeon removes the thin bone between the lacrimal sac and the nose and joins the lining of the sac to the nasal mucosa, so tears pass straight from the sac into the nose above the level of the obstruction. It works only if the canaliculi are open, which is why probing and syringing come first.

There are two approaches. External DCR is done through a small skin incision on the side of the nose, gives a direct view and allows the sac to be inspected and biopsied. Success is reported in up to 90 to 95% of cases. Endonasal (endoscopic) DCR is done from inside the nose with an endoscope and leaves no scar. Many series report similar success with the endonasal approach, but a Cochrane review found only two small trials and concluded that the relative success of the two approaches is uncertain. Fine silicone tubes are often passed through both canaliculi and the new opening and removed some weeks later.

The main complications are bleeding from the nose, infection, and failure with return of watering, which is usually caused by scar tissue closing the new opening. Leak of cerebrospinal fluid is a rare risk because the roof of the nose is close to the operative field. In children, congenital nasolacrimal duct obstruction is managed differently, by waiting and then probing, as described in the paediatric chapter.

Summary

  • Tears drain through the puncta, canaliculi, common canaliculus, lacrimal sac and nasolacrimal duct to the inferior meatus of the nose.
  • Drainage depends on the blink-driven lacrimal pump, so facial palsy causes watering with open ducts.
  • A watery eye is either reflex overproduction, often from dry eye and blepharitis, or impaired drainage.
  • Retained dye at five minutes on the fluorescein dye disappearance test indicates impaired drainage.
  • On probing, a hard stop means the canaliculus is open and a soft stop means it is blocked.
  • On syringing, mucus regurgitating from the opposite punctum indicates nasolacrimal duct obstruction.
  • Canaliculitis is usually due to Actinomyces israelii: pouting punctum, concretions, and cure by canaliculotomy.
  • Acute dacryocystitis is a tender swelling below the medial canthal tendon; treat with systemic antibiotics and do not probe.
  • Dacryocystorhinostomy joins the lacrimal sac to the nasal mucosa through a bony opening and needs patent canaliculi.
  • Blocked canaliculi that cannot be reopened are bypassed with a Lester Jones tube.

Check yourself

Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.

1. On probing, the cannula reaches bone, and on syringing mucus-stained saline regurgitates from the upper punctum. Where is the blockage?
2. Which organism classically causes canaliculitis?
3. Where does the nasolacrimal duct open?
4. What should be avoided in acute dacryocystitis?
Practise 4 questions on this lesson

Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.