Macular hole, epiretinal membrane and vitreomacular traction
Three conditions arise where the ageing vitreous meets the macula: vitreomacular traction, macular hole and epiretinal membrane. All three distort central vision, all three are diagnosed on optical coherence tomography, and all three are treated by vitrectomy when they need treating. This lesson explains how one process, an incomplete vitreous detachment, produces each of them and how to tell them apart.
One process, three diseases
The previous lessons described the posterior hyaloid, the outer skin of the vitreous, peeling off the retina with age. The process starts around the fovea and spreads outwards, but the hyaloid is stuck firmly at the fovea itself, so the centre is often the last part of the macula to let go. For a time the gel is detached all around the fovea and attached only at its centre.
3D atlasThe posterior hyaloid is firmly attached at the fovea, the thinnest part of the retina.If the hyaloid then separates cleanly, nothing happens. Trouble comes when the separation is abnormal, and there are three ways it can go wrong.
- The hyaloid stays attached at the fovea and pulls it forwards: vitreomacular traction.
- The pull opens a full-thickness defect in the fovea: a macular hole.
- The hyaloid separates but leaves cells behind on the retinal surface, which grow into a contracting sheet: an epiretinal membrane.
The shared symptom is metamorphopsia, distortion of straight lines. The fovea's photoreceptors are packed in a precise mosaic, and the brain assumes each one sits in its usual place. Pull the mosaic out of shape and a straight door frame looks bent. Patients notice it when reading or on an Amsler grid, a printed square grid viewed with one eye at a time.
Vitreomacular traction
Optical coherence tomography (OCT) gives a cross-section of the macula and has defined this group of conditions. Two terms need separating. In vitreomacular adhesion the hyaloid has lifted off around the fovea but is still attached at the centre, and the foveal contour is normal. This is a stage of normal ageing with no symptoms. In vitreomacular traction (VMT) the same attachment is distorting the retina.
On OCT, VMT appears as a thin bright line, the hyaloid, lifted off the retina on both sides and converging on the fovea, which is pulled up into a peak. The normal foveal dip is lost and dark fluid-filled cysts may appear within the retina. The attachment is called focal if it is 1,500 micrometres wide or less, and broad if wider.
Patients have mild blurring and distortion. Some cases release on their own when the hyaloid finally separates, so mild VMT is observed with repeat OCT. Persistent traction with worsening vision is treated by vitrectomy to remove the hyaloid. An intravitreal enzyme injection, ocriplasmin, was developed to dissolve the attachment, but in the trials it released traction in only about a quarter of eyes.
Macular hole
A full-thickness macular hole is a defect through every layer of the neurosensory retina at the fovea, from the internal limiting membrane down to the retinal pigment epithelium. Most are idiopathic, meaning they result from vitreous traction in an otherwise normal eye. They typically affect people aged 60 and over and are commoner in women. Other causes are blunt trauma and high myopia. The fellow eye is at risk if its vitreous is still attached, and once it has a complete vitreous detachment the risk is low.
The patient notices distortion first and then a central blur or gap, with letters missing from the middle of words. Peripheral vision is untouched, so navigation is normal. Acuity falls as the hole enlarges.
Gass described the development in four stages, which make sense as steps in the traction story.
- Stage 1, impending hole: traction lifts the fovea. The foveal dip is lost and a yellow spot (1A) or yellow ring (1B) is seen. There is no full-thickness defect yet, and about half resolve if the vitreous lets go.
- Stage 2: a small full-thickness hole, under 400 micrometres across, usually with the hyaloid still attached to its edge.
- Stage 3: a full-thickness hole of 400 micrometres or more, often with a grey cuff of subretinal fluid around it. The hyaloid has separated from the macula, sometimes carrying a small lid of tissue (an operculum).
- Stage 4: a full-thickness hole with a complete posterior vitreous detachment and a Weiss ring.
A newer OCT classification ignores stages and records the narrowest width of the hole as small (250 micrometres or less), medium (250 to 400) or large (over 400), and whether VMT is present. On OCT a full-thickness hole is unmistakable: a gap through all retinal layers, with rounded, thickened edges that contain dark cystic spaces and curl slightly upwards.
Surgery for a macular hole
Full-thickness holes rarely close on their own, so they are treated surgically, and smaller, more recent holes do best. The operation has three steps, each aimed at a force holding the hole open.
- Pars plana vitrectomy removes the vitreous and detaches the posterior hyaloid, ending the front-to-back traction.
- Internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling: the ILM is the basement membrane on the inner surface of the retina. It is stained with a dye such as Brilliant Blue so that it can be seen, then peeled from around the hole with fine forceps. This removes any sideways (tangential) traction and the scaffold on which cells could regrow.
- Gas tamponade: the eye is filled with a gas bubble. The bubble bridges the hole, keeps fluid out of it and lets the edges come together and heal.
Because the macula is at the back of the eye and gas floats, patients have traditionally been asked to posture face down afterwards so that the bubble presses on the hole. How strictly and for how long is debated: a Cochrane review of eight randomised trials found low-certainty evidence that face-down positioning makes little or no difference to closure overall, with any benefit most likely in larger holes, and many surgeons now relax it for smaller holes. Single-operation closure rates are around 90%. The usual gas rules apply: no flying and no nitrous oxide until the bubble has gone. Cataract follows vitrectomy so regularly in patients who still have their own lens that it is expected.
Epiretinal membrane
An epiretinal membrane is a thin, semi-transparent sheet of scar-like tissue growing on the inner surface of the retina, on top of the ILM. Glial cells and retinal pigment epithelial cells are its main components. Some of the cells behave like myofibroblasts and contract, and it is the contraction that causes symptoms. Older names describe the same thing by appearance: cellophane maculopathy for a mild glistening film and macular pucker for a thick membrane that has wrinkled the retina.
Most membranes are idiopathic and follow a posterior vitreous detachment. They are common, found in roughly 7 to 11% of people, and commoner with age. Secondary membranes follow anything that sheds cells or causes inflammation at the retinal surface: retinal tears and detachment surgery, retinal vein occlusion, diabetic retinopathy, uveitis and trauma.
The great majority cause no symptoms and are found by chance. When the membrane contracts, the patient has distortion, blurring, and sometimes objects looking a different size in the affected eye. The fundus shows a glistening sheen at the macula, fine wrinkles in the retinal surface and retinal vessels dragged out of their normal course. On OCT the membrane is a bright line lying on the inner retinal surface. Beneath it the retina is thickened, its surface is thrown into folds and the foveal dip is flattened or lost.
Treatment depends on symptoms, not on appearance. A membrane that does not trouble the patient is left alone. One that causes significant distortion or visual loss is removed by vitrectomy and membrane peel, often taking the ILM as well to reduce the chance of regrowth. No gas is needed unless there is a hole or tear. Vision and distortion improve slowly over months, usually without returning fully to normal.
Telling the three apart
| Vitreomacular traction | Full-thickness macular hole | Epiretinal membrane | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Hyaloid still attached at the fovea and pulling | Traction opens a defect through the fovea | Cells on the retinal surface form a contracting sheet |
| Symptoms | Mild blur and distortion | Distortion, then a central gap | Often none. Distortion if it contracts |
| Watzke-Allen sign | Negative | Positive: the line is broken | Negative |
| OCT in words | Bright line converging on a peaked fovea | Gap through all retinal layers with thickened, cystic edges | Bright line on the surface with wrinkled, thickened retina beneath |
| Natural course | May release spontaneously | Rarely closes. Tends to enlarge | Usually stable |
| Surgery | Vitrectomy if persistent | Vitrectomy, ILM peel and gas | Vitrectomy and membrane peel if symptomatic |
Summary
- Vitreomacular traction, macular hole and epiretinal membrane all arise from abnormal separation of the posterior hyaloid at the macula.
- Metamorphopsia, distortion of straight lines, is the shared symptom and is checked with an Amsler grid.
- Vitreomacular adhesion has a normal foveal contour, whereas vitreomacular traction distorts the fovea.
- A full-thickness macular hole is a defect through all layers of the neurosensory retina at the fovea, typically in women over 60.
- In the Gass staging, stage 1 is an impending hole, stages 2 and 3 are full-thickness holes below and above 400 micrometres, and stage 4 has a complete vitreous detachment.
- A positive Watzke-Allen sign is a break in the slit beam and indicates a full-thickness hole.
- Macular hole surgery is vitrectomy, internal limiting membrane peel and gas tamponade, traditionally with face-down posturing.
- An epiretinal membrane is a contracting fibrocellular sheet on the retinal surface that is common and usually symptomless.
- Epiretinal membranes are peeled only when distortion or visual loss troubles the patient.
- Pseudoholes and lamellar holes look like holes clinically but have retinal tissue across the fovea on OCT.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.