Visual development and amblyopia
A baby is born with eyes that work but a visual brain that has not yet learned to use them. That learning happens in the first years of life and depends on each eye sending the brain a sharp, aligned image. This lesson explains normal visual development, the critical period, the three causes of amblyopia, how it is treated, and why the UK screens vision at age 4 to 5.
How vision develops
At birth the eye is structurally close to complete, but vision is poor. The fovea is immature, the optic nerve is not fully myelinated, and the connections in the visual cortex are still forming. Acuity improves fastest in the first six months and then more slowly through early childhood.
A student does not need a long table of milestones, but a few anchor points are examined because they are the ones checked in UK child health reviews.
- Newborn: the pupils react to light and the baby blinks to a bright light. The eyes may look misaligned from time to time.
- By 6 to 8 weeks: the baby looks steadily at a face, follows it, and smiles back. The NHS infant examination at 6 to 8 weeks checks that the baby can fix on the examiner's face without nystagmus and follow a bright target with the eyes.
- By about 3 months: the eyes should be straight. The NHS advises that a squint that comes and goes is common up to 3 months, but a squint that is constant, or any squint after 3 months, needs assessment.
- Early childhood: acuity, binocular vision and depth perception continue to mature for several years.
The critical period
The visual cortex is wired by use. In early life the neurones that receive input from the two eyes compete for connections. If both eyes send a clear, matching image, the cortex shares its territory between them and learns to combine them. If one eye sends a blurred, absent or misdirected image, its connections lose the competition and the cortex comes to be driven mainly by the other eye.
This was shown in the animal experiments of Hubel and Wiesel, in which closing one eye of a young animal for a short time shrank that eye's share of the visual cortex (its ocular dominance columns) permanently, while the same closure in an adult had no effect. The window during which the cortex can be shaped in this way is the critical period (also called the sensitive period).
In humans the critical period runs from birth to roughly 7 to 10 years. Sensitivity is greatest in the first months and falls steadily. Two consequences follow, and both are examined. First, the earlier an obstacle to vision appears, the more damage it does: a dense cataract present at birth is far more harmful than the same cataract at age 6. Second, the same plasticity that allows the damage also allows repair, so treatment works best when it is started young. The NHS advises that treatment should ideally start before the age of 7. Some improvement is still possible in older children and teenagers, but it is smaller.
What amblyopia is and its three causes
Amblyopia (lazy eye) is reduced best-corrected visual acuity in one eye, or less often both, caused by abnormal visual experience during the critical period and not explained by a structural abnormality of the eye. The eye itself looks normal. The fault is in the brain's use of it. Estimates of how common it is vary, but figures of about 2 to 3% of children are typical.
There are three mechanisms. In each, think about what the cortex is being sent.
| Strabismic | Anisometropic | Stimulus deprivation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What goes wrong | The eyes point in different directions, so the two images do not match | The two eyes have unequal refractive errors, so one image is always blurred | Something blocks the image from forming at all |
| How the brain responds | Suppresses the image from the squinting eye to avoid double vision | Favours the sharper image and neglects the blurred one | Receives little or no patterned input from that eye |
| Typical causes | Constant squint in one eye, esotropia more than exotropia | Unequal hypermetropia or astigmatism | Congenital cataract, severe ptosis, corneal opacity, prolonged patching |
| How it presents | Visible squint | Nothing to see, often found only at screening | Abnormal red reflex or a drooping lid covering the pupil |
| Severity | Variable | Variable | Usually the most severe and the most urgent |
Anisometropia means a difference in refractive error between the two eyes. Hypermetropic anisometropia is especially amblyogenic because accommodation is equal in both eyes: the child accommodates just enough to focus the better eye, and the more long-sighted eye is never in focus at any distance. When both eyes have a high uncorrected error, both can become amblyopic.
A child who swaps fixation freely between the two eyes (alternates) uses each eye in turn and is much less likely to become amblyopic than a child who always fixes with the same eye.
Detecting amblyopia
Amblyopia is diagnosed when acuity in one eye is still reduced after the refractive error has been corrected and the eye has been examined and found structurally normal. A cycloplegic refraction and a dilated fundus examination are therefore part of every assessment, because retinoblastoma, optic nerve disease and cataract can all present as a child with one poorly seeing eye.
Amblyopic eyes show the crowding phenomenon: they read a single isolated letter much better than the same letter in a row surrounded by others. Testing with single letters therefore underestimates amblyopia, and children are tested with crowded charts, in which each letter has neighbours or a surrounding box.
Before a child can read letters, vision is judged by behaviour. A baby who objects strongly when one eye is covered but not the other is probably seeing poorly with the uncovered eye. Fixation preference, picture matching and preferential looking cards are used by orthoptists until a crowded letter test becomes possible at around 3 to 4 years.
Treatment: clear the image, then force the eye to work
Treatment follows the mechanism and is done in a fixed order.
- Remove any obstacle. A cataract is removed or a lid lifted so that an image can form.
- Correct the refractive error. Glasses are prescribed from the cycloplegic refraction and worn full time. Glasses alone improve acuity over the following weeks to months, a period called refractive adaptation. In one study of children aged 3 to 6, about three quarters gained two lines or more with glasses alone.
- Occlusion. If acuity is still unequal, the better eye is covered with a patch for part of each day so that the brain has to use the amblyopic eye.
- Penalisation, as an alternative to a patch. Atropine 1% drops in the better eye paralyse its accommodation and blur its near vision, so the child prefers the amblyopic eye.
The American Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group (PEDIG) trials shaped modern practice. For moderate amblyopia, 2 hours of patching a day worked as well as 6 hours. For severe amblyopia, 6 hours a day worked as well as full-time patching. Atropine gave similar acuity to patching at 6 months, although patching worked faster at first, and atropine given only at weekends was as good as daily drops for moderate amblyopia.
| Occlusion (patch) | Atropine penalisation | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Blocks the better eye | Blurs the better eye by cycloplegia |
| Speed | Faster initial improvement | Slower, similar result by 6 months |
| Main problem | Poor compliance, skin irritation, teasing | Photophobia from the dilated pupil, rare systemic antimuscarinic effects |
| Usual role in the UK | First choice | When patching is not tolerated |
NICE's Clinical Knowledge Summary notes that poor compliance with occlusion is the single greatest barrier to improvement. It lists the systemic effects of atropine drops as uncommon, and they are the antimuscarinic ones: flushing, dry mouth, fever, tachycardia and restlessness. Parents must be reminded that the drops go in the good eye.
Two risks of treatment are worth knowing. Covering the good eye too much in a very young child can make it amblyopic in turn (occlusion or reverse amblyopia), so treated children are reviewed regularly. Amblyopia also recurs in around a fifth to a quarter of children after treatment stops, more often if heavy patching is stopped abruptly, so treatment is tapered and vision is followed afterwards.
UK child vision screening at 4 to 5 years
Anisometropic amblyopia has no outward sign, and a small squint is easy to miss, so many amblyopic children would be found too late without screening. The UK National Screening Committee recommends vision screening for all children aged 4 to 5. This is old enough for a reliable letter test and young enough for treatment to work.
- It is commissioned by local authorities and is orthoptist-led: carried out by an orthoptist or by a screener whose competence an orthoptist has confirmed, usually at school.
- The test is a crowded logMAR letter test (the Keeler crowded logMAR test), with each eye tested separately.
- A child who cannot reach 0.20 logMAR (about 6/9.5) in one or both eyes is referred.
- Referred children have an orthoptic assessment of eye movements and binocular function, a cycloplegic refraction, and an examination of the media and fundus.
The target condition is amblyopia, together with the squint and refractive error that cause it. The newborn and 6 to 8 week examinations are a different programme with a different target, mainly congenital cataract.
Summary
- Intermittent misalignment of the eyes is common up to 3 months, but a constant squint or any squint after 3 months needs assessment.
- The critical period, from birth to about 7 to 10 years, is the time when abnormal visual input can permanently reduce the cortical response to an eye.
- Amblyopia is reduced best-corrected acuity from abnormal visual experience in early life in an eye that is structurally normal.
- The three causes are strabismus, anisometropia and stimulus deprivation, and deprivation is the most severe and most urgent.
- Amblyopic eyes show crowding, so vision is tested with crowded letter charts.
- Treatment order is to clear the media, correct the refractive error with glasses, then patch or atropine-penalise the better eye.
- Patching acts faster than atropine but both reach similar acuity, and poor compliance is the main reason treatment fails.
- Amblyopia can recur after treatment stops, and overtreatment can cause amblyopia in the covered eye.
- UK children are screened at age 4 to 5 by an orthoptist-led service using a crowded logMAR test, with referral if either eye is worse than 0.20 logMAR.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.