Astigmatism and its correction
In astigmatism the eye has different powers in different meridians, so a point of light is never focused to a point. This lesson explains the shape of the focus (Sturm's conoid), how astigmatism is classified and named, how it is corrected, and how the cross cylinder is used to refine the cylinder in a prescription.
What astigmatism is
A spherical refracting surface, like the side of a football, has the same curvature in every direction and brings light to a single point. An astigmatic surface is more like the side of a rugby ball: steeper in one direction than in the direction at right angles to it. The steeper direction has more power. The word astigmatism means without a point, and that is the essence of it: there is no single point focus anywhere.
Directions across the eye are called meridians. The two meridians of greatest and least power are the principal meridians. In regular astigmatism they are at right angles to each other and each is uniform across the pupil. This is the common form and it can be corrected with a cylindrical lens. In irregular astigmatism the principal meridians are not at right angles, or the power varies from place to place across the pupil. It cannot be fully corrected with spectacles.
Most astigmatism arises at the cornea, the eye's most powerful surface, where a small difference in curvature has a large effect. Some arises in the lens, from its shape, tilt or position. This is lenticular astigmatism. The two can add or partly cancel.
Sturm's conoid
Consider parallel light passing through a toric surface whose vertical meridian is stronger than its horizontal meridian. The vertical meridian converges the rays in the vertical plane, and because it is stronger, these come together first. At that moment the rays have not yet come together in the horizontal plane, so the light forms a horizontal line. Further back, the weaker horizontal meridian brings the rays together side to side, but by then the vertical rays have crossed and spread again, so the light forms a vertical line.
So each meridian forms a focal line at right angles to itself, and the stronger meridian's line is nearer the lens. The three-dimensional bundle of rays between and around the two lines is Sturm's conoid, and the distance between the lines is the interval of Sturm. The greater the astigmatism, the longer the interval. Between the lines the cross-section of the beam is an ellipse, except at one place where it is round. This is the circle of least confusion, the nearest thing to a focus that an astigmatic system has. It lies at the dioptric midpoint of the two lines, which corresponds to the spherical equivalent.
Position of each focal line = 1 / power of that meridianThe circle of least confusion lies at 1 / (average of the two powers).Worked example 1. A lens is +3.00 / +2.00 x 180. The cylinder axis is horizontal, so its power acts vertically. The vertical meridian is +5.00 D and the horizontal meridian is +3.00 D. For parallel light, the vertical meridian forms a horizontal line at 1 / 5 m = 20 cm. The horizontal meridian forms a vertical line at 1 / 3 m = 33 cm. The interval of Sturm runs from 20 to 33 cm. The circle of least confusion is at the average power, +4.00 D, which is 25 cm. Note that it is at the dioptric midpoint, not halfway in centimetres.
Classifying regular astigmatism by focus
The first classification asks where the two focal lines fall relative to the retina when accommodation is relaxed. Reading the type from a prescription only takes a power cross: the sphere is the power of one principal meridian and the sphere plus the cylinder is the power of the other.
| Type | Position of the focal lines | Example | Meridian powers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple myopic | One on the retina, one in front | Plano / -1.00 x 180 | 0 and -1.00 |
| Compound myopic | Both in front | -1.00 / -1.00 x 180 | -1.00 and -2.00 |
| Simple hypermetropic | One on the retina, one behind | +1.00 / -1.00 x 180 | +1.00 and 0 |
| Compound hypermetropic | Both behind | +2.00 / -1.00 x 180 | +2.00 and +1.00 |
| Mixed | One in front, one behind | +1.00 / -2.00 x 180 | +1.00 and -1.00 |
Worked example 2. Classify -1.00 / -2.00 x 90. One meridian needs -1.00 and the other needs -1.00 + (-2.00) = -3.00. Both are minus, so both focal lines lie in front of the retina: compound myopic astigmatism. The spherical equivalent is -1.00 + (-1.00) = -2.00 D. Now classify +0.50 / -1.50 x 90. The meridians are +0.50 and -1.00, one each side of the retina: mixed astigmatism.
With the rule, against the rule and oblique
The second classification describes the orientation of the steep meridian. In with-the-rule astigmatism the vertical meridian is the steeper one. It is the usual pattern in young eyes, and it is attributed to the pressure of the lids on the cornea. In against-the-rule astigmatism the horizontal meridian is steeper. Corneal astigmatism tends to shift in this direction from middle age onwards. In oblique astigmatism the principal meridians lie well away from the vertical and horizontal.
The correcting cylinder follows from the optics. If the vertical meridian is too powerful, a minus cylinder is needed whose power acts vertically. A cylinder's power acts at right angles to its axis, so the axis must be horizontal, at or near 180.
| With the rule | Against the rule | |
|---|---|---|
| Steeper meridian | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Minus cylinder axis | Near 180 | Near 90 |
| Plus cylinder axis | Near 90 | Near 180 |
| Typical age | Children and young adults | More common in later life |
Worked example 3. Keratometry shows a corneal power of 44.00 D in the vertical meridian and 42.50 D in the horizontal. The corneal astigmatism is the difference, 1.50 D. The vertical meridian is steeper, so it is with the rule, and the correcting cylinder would be about -1.50 D with its axis at 180.
Irregular astigmatism
Irregular astigmatism comes from an uneven corneal surface. Causes include keratoconus and other ectasias, corneal scars after injury or infection, and surgery such as corneal grafting. On retinoscopy the reflex is distorted and cannot be neutralised cleanly, and acuity stays reduced with the best spectacle lenses. A pinhole usually improves it, which points to an optical cause.
The classic optical treatment is a rigid contact lens. Its smooth front surface becomes the new refracting surface, and the tears that fill the gap between the lens and the uneven cornea have almost the same refractive index as the cornea, so the irregularities are optically cancelled. Corneal topography maps the irregularity. The cornea lessons cover keratoconus itself.
Correcting regular astigmatism
Regular astigmatism is corrected by collapsing the interval of Sturm to a point and placing that point on the retina. A cylinder does the first job by adding power to one meridian only, and a sphere does the second. Combined in one lens they make a toric spectacle lens. Toric soft contact lenses, rigid contact lenses, toric intraocular lenses and corneal laser surgery are alternatives.
If a cylinder cannot be used or is not tolerated, the spherical equivalent is prescribed. This leaves the interval of Sturm unchanged but puts the circle of least confusion on the retina, the best compromise available. Small amounts of astigmatism, up to about 0.50 D, often need no correction unless they cause symptoms. In young children significant uncorrected astigmatism can cause amblyopia, so it is corrected early.
The cross cylinder
The Jackson cross cylinder is a small lens on a handle used to refine the axis and then the power of the cylinder during subjective refraction. It has equal and opposite powers in its two principal meridians: for example +0.25 D in one and -0.25 D in the other, which can be written +0.25 DS / -0.50 DC. Its spherical equivalent is zero. Putting it in front of the eye therefore stretches or shrinks the interval of Sturm without moving the circle of least confusion. The handle is set at 45 degrees to the two axes, so twirling the handle swaps the plus and minus meridians.
- Start with the best sphere, so that the circle of least confusion is on the retina.
- Refine the axis first. Hold the cross cylinder with its handle along the axis of the trial cylinder and flip it. If the patient prefers one position, rotate the trial cylinder towards the cross cylinder axis of the same sign, and repeat until the two positions look equally blurred.
- Refine the power second. Turn the cross cylinder so that one of its axes lies along the trial cylinder axis and flip it. If the view is better when the cross cylinder adds to the trial cylinder, increase the cylinder. If it is better when it subtracts, reduce it.
- Keep the spherical equivalent constant. For every 0.50 D of minus cylinder added, add +0.25 D to the sphere.
- Stop when both positions look the same.
The axis is refined before the power because the correct power cannot be judged while the cylinder is at the wrong axis. The sphere is adjusted in step 4 because adding -0.50 D of cylinder changes the spherical equivalent by -0.25 D, which would move the circle of least confusion off the retina.
Summary
- Astigmatism means the eye has different powers in different meridians, so there is no point focus.
- In regular astigmatism the principal meridians are at right angles and it is correctable with a cylinder.
- Each principal meridian forms a focal line at right angles to itself, and the stronger meridian's line is nearer the lens.
- The circle of least confusion lies at the dioptric midpoint of the interval of Sturm and corresponds to the spherical equivalent.
- With-the-rule astigmatism has a steeper vertical meridian and is corrected by a minus cylinder at 180 or a plus cylinder at 90.
- Against-the-rule astigmatism has a steeper horizontal meridian and becomes more common with age.
- Astigmatism is simple, compound or mixed according to where the two focal lines lie relative to the retina.
- Irregular astigmatism, as in keratoconus, is best corrected optically with a rigid contact lens.
- The Jackson cross cylinder has a spherical equivalent of zero and refines the axis first, then the power.
- When changing the cylinder by 0.50 D, the sphere is changed by 0.25 D in the opposite direction.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.