Gaze disorders, internuclear ophthalmoplegia and nystagmus
The last lesson dealt with single nerves. This one moves up a level, to the brainstem circuits that make the two eyes move together, and to the rhythmic oscillations that appear when those circuits or the balance system fail. The aim is to localise: each pattern of gaze palsy or nystagmus points to a particular place.
Levels of control
Eye movements are organised in three levels. At the bottom are the muscles and the three nerves that supply them. In the middle are the nuclei of those nerves and the short tracts that link them. Above them are the supranuclear centres in the brainstem, cortex and cerebellum, which do not move one eye but command both eyes to move together in a direction. This is called conjugate gaze.
The level decides the symptom. A nerve or muscle lesion misaligns the eyes and causes double vision. A supranuclear lesion stops both eyes moving in one direction but leaves them aligned, so the patient usually has no double vision. A second test separates them. The doll's head manoeuvre turns the patient's head while they fix on a target. This drives the eyes through the vestibular reflex, which enters the brainstem below the supranuclear centres. If the eyes move fully with the manoeuvre but not on command, the lesion is supranuclear.
Horizontal gaze and the pons
To look to the right, the right lateral rectus and the left medial rectus must contract together. The circuit is as follows.
- The frontal eye field of the left hemisphere starts a rapid eye movement (a saccade) to the right. Each frontal eye field drives gaze to the opposite side.
- The command crosses to the right paramedian pontine reticular formation (PPRF), the horizontal gaze centre.
- The PPRF excites the right abducens nucleus. This nucleus contains two kinds of cell: motor neurones to the right lateral rectus, and interneurones.
- The interneurones cross the midline at once and climb in the left medial longitudinal fasciculus (MLF) to the medial rectus part of the left third nerve nucleus, so the left eye adducts.
Three lesions follow from the circuit. A lesion of one frontal eye field, as in a hemisphere stroke, removes the drive to the opposite side, so the eyes drift towards the lesion and away from the paralysed limbs. This usually recovers within days. A lesion of the PPRF or the abducens nucleus causes a gaze palsy to the same side: neither eye can look that way, and the eyes rest looking away from the lesion. Note that a lesion of the abducens nucleus gives a gaze palsy, while a lesion of the abducens nerve gives only an abduction deficit in one eye. The third lesion, of the MLF, is the subject of the next section.
Internuclear ophthalmoplegia and the one-and-a-half syndrome
A lesion of the MLF disconnects the abducens nucleus from the opposite medial rectus. This is internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO). On gaze away from the side of the lesion there are two signs.
- The eye on the side of the lesion fails to adduct, or adducts slowly. In mild cases the only sign is a lag of the adducting eye during fast side-to-side saccades.
- The other eye abducts fully but shows nystagmus as it does so.
The INO is named after the side of the adduction failure, which is the side of the MLF lesion. Convergence is usually preserved: the same eye that cannot adduct on side gaze can turn in to look at a near target. This proves that the medial rectus, its nerve and its nucleus are intact and that the fault lies in the pathway carrying the side-gaze command. The MLF is heavily myelinated and the two fasciculi lie next to each other at the midline, which explains the causes. In young adults the usual cause is multiple sclerosis, and the INO is often bilateral. In older patients it is a small brainstem stroke, usually unilateral. A bilateral INO in which both eyes also drift outward is called wall-eyed bilateral INO (WEBINO).
The one-and-a-half syndrome is caused by a single lesion in the dorsal pons that damages the PPRF or abducens nucleus on one side and the MLF on the same side. The first lesion causes a gaze palsy to that side (the one). The second causes an INO on that side, so the eye also fails to adduct when looking the other way (the half). Of the four horizontal movements of the two eyes, three are lost. The only horizontal movement left is abduction of the opposite eye, with nystagmus. Vertical movements and convergence are normal. Stroke is the commonest cause in adults, followed by demyelination and tumour. If the facial nerve fascicle, which loops around the abducens nucleus, is also caught, a lower motor neurone facial palsy is added, and seven plus one and a half gives the name eight-and-a-half syndrome.
| Lesion | Looking right | Looking left | Double vision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Right sixth nerve | Right eye fails to abduct | Normal | Yes |
| Right PPRF or abducens nucleus | Neither eye moves right | Normal | No |
| Right MLF (right INO) | Normal | Right eye fails to adduct; left eye abducts with nystagmus | On left gaze |
| Right one-and-a-half syndrome | Neither eye moves right | Right eye fails to adduct; left eye abducts with nystagmus | Often |
Vertical gaze and the dorsal midbrain
The centres for vertical gaze lie in the upper midbrain, next to the aqueduct. The rostral interstitial nucleus of the MLF generates vertical saccades and the interstitial nucleus of Cajal holds vertical gaze steady. Fibres for upgaze cross in the posterior commissure, at the very back of the midbrain, where they are exposed to pressure from behind.
Dorsal midbrain syndrome (Parinaud syndrome) is the result of pressure on or damage to this region. It has four signs.
- Upgaze palsy. The patient cannot look up, at first for saccades. A baby with hydrocephalus shows the eyes driven downward, the setting sun sign.
- Convergence-retraction nystagmus. On attempting to look up quickly, the eyes jerk inwards and pull back into the orbits, because all the recti contract at once.
- Light-near dissociation. The pupils are mid-dilated and react poorly to light but constrict to a near target, because the light reflex fibres cross in the dorsal midbrain.
- Lid retraction (the Collier sign), giving a startled look.
The classic causes are a pineal region tumour in a child or young adult, hydrocephalus (including a blocked shunt), and midbrain stroke or haemorrhage. Multiple sclerosis can also cause it.
Two related conditions are worth a sentence each. Progressive supranuclear palsy, a degenerative disease of older people with falls and rigidity, impairs vertical saccades, classically downgaze first. Skew deviation is a vertical misalignment of the eyes caused by a brainstem or cerebellar lesion that disturbs input from the balance organs. It can look like a fourth nerve palsy but comes with other brainstem signs.
Nystagmus: describing it
Nystagmus is an involuntary, rhythmic, to-and-fro movement of the eyes. It begins with a slow drift of the eyes off the target, which is the fault. What happens next defines the type. In jerk nystagmus a fast corrective saccade brings the eyes back, giving a slow phase and a fast phase. By convention it is named after the fast phase, although the slow phase is the abnormal part. In pendular nystagmus the eyes swing back at the same speed, like a pendulum.
Jerk nystagmus usually obeys Alexander's law: it gets stronger when the patient looks in the direction of the fast phase. Acquired nystagmus makes the world appear to move (oscillopsia). Nystagmus present from infancy does not, because the brain has adapted. A few beats of fine nystagmus at the extreme of side gaze are normal.
The commonest abnormal form in adults is gaze-evoked nystagmus. The eyes cannot be held in an off-centre position, drift back towards the centre and are flicked out again, so the nystagmus beats to the right on right gaze and to the left on left gaze. It reflects failure of the gaze-holding system in the brainstem and cerebellum, and the usual causes are alcohol, sedatives and anticonvulsants, and cerebellar disease.
| Peripheral (inner ear or vestibular nerve) | Central (brainstem or cerebellum) | |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Horizontal with a torsional element; fast phase always beats the same way, away from the damaged ear | Purely vertical, purely torsional, or changes direction with gaze |
| Effect of fixing on a target | Suppressed | Not suppressed |
| Vertigo, nausea | Severe | Mild or absent |
| Hearing loss, tinnitus | May be present | Absent |
| Other neurological signs | None | Often present |
| Course | Settles over days | Persists |
Nystagmus: types that localise
Some forms of nystagmus are so strongly linked to one site that they are asked as pairs.
| Type | What is seen | Localises to | Typical causes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Downbeat | Fast phase down in the straight-ahead position, worse on looking down and to the side | Craniocervical junction and cerebellum | Chiari malformation, cerebellar degeneration, lithium, anticonvulsants |
| Upbeat | Fast phase up in the straight-ahead position | Brainstem or anterior cerebellar vermis | Multiple sclerosis, stroke, tumour |
| See-saw | One eye rises and intorts (its top rotates towards the nose) while the other falls and extorts, then the reverse | Chiasm and parasellar region | Craniopharyngioma, large pituitary adenoma |
| Periodic alternating | Horizontal jerk nystagmus that beats one way for 30 to 90 seconds, pauses, then beats the other way | Cerebellum | Cerebellar disease, multiple sclerosis, phenytoin toxicity |
| Convergence-retraction | Eyes converge and retract on attempted upgaze | Dorsal midbrain | Pineal tumour, hydrocephalus |
| Abducting nystagmus of one eye | Nystagmus only in the abducting eye | Medial longitudinal fasciculus | Multiple sclerosis, stroke |
| Acquired pendular | Pendular movement in several planes | Brainstem and cerebellar connections | Multiple sclerosis is the commonest cause |
Infantile nystagmus, formerly called congenital nystagmus, appears in the first few months of life. It is horizontal and conjugate, and it stays horizontal even on looking up or down, which is unusual for acquired nystagmus. It dampens on convergence and disappears in sleep. Most patients have a null point, a direction of gaze in which the movement is least, and they turn the head to put the eyes there. It may occur on its own or with poor vision from early life, as in albinism, aniridia, congenital cataract or an inherited retinal dystrophy, so every infant with nystagmus needs a full eye examination.
Latent nystagmus is a horizontal jerk nystagmus that appears only when one eye is covered, beating towards the uncovered eye. It is associated with infantile esotropia. It matters in practice because covering one eye to test acuity makes the vision appear worse than it is. Fogging the other eye with a plus lens avoids this. Spasmus nutans is a triad of fine, asymmetric nystagmus, head nodding and a head tilt beginning in the first year of life. It resolves on its own, but a chiasmal glioma can produce the same picture, so imaging is usually arranged.
Summary
- Supranuclear lesions cause loss of conjugate gaze without double vision, and reflex eye movements with the doll's head manoeuvre are preserved.
- Each frontal eye field drives gaze to the opposite side; the PPRF and abducens nucleus drive gaze to the same side.
- The MLF carries interneurones from the abducens nucleus to the opposite medial rectus subnucleus.
- INO: the eye on the side of the MLF lesion fails to adduct, the other eye shows abducting nystagmus, and convergence is usually spared.
- INO in a young adult suggests multiple sclerosis (often bilateral); in an older patient, brainstem stroke.
- One-and-a-half syndrome is a gaze palsy plus INO on the same side: only abduction of the opposite eye remains.
- Dorsal midbrain (Parinaud) syndrome is upgaze palsy, convergence-retraction nystagmus, light-near dissociation and lid retraction, from pineal tumour or hydrocephalus.
- Jerk nystagmus is named after its fast phase and increases on gaze towards the fast phase (Alexander's law).
- Downbeat nystagmus localises to the craniocervical junction, see-saw nystagmus to the chiasm, and purely vertical or direction-changing nystagmus is central.
- Infantile nystagmus is horizontal in all positions of gaze, has a null point, dampens on convergence and causes no oscillopsia.
Check yourself
Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.
Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.