Skip to content
Pass Duke Elder
Textbook / Chapter 10 / Neuro-ophthalmology

Abnormal pupils

Unequal pupils are a favourite exam topic because a few simple observations localise the lesion exactly. This lesson gives a method for anisocoria, then works through Horner syndrome, the third nerve pupil, the Adie tonic pupil, pharmacological mydriasis, Argyll Robertson pupils and the relative afferent pupillary defect.

10 minute read10 linked questions

Two muscles, two nerve supplies

Pupil size is a balance between two iris muscles. The sphincter pupillae is a ring of muscle at the pupil margin. It constricts the pupil and is driven by parasympathetic fibres that travel with the third cranial nerve, synapse in the ciliary ganglion in the orbit and reach the eye in the short ciliary nerves. The dilator pupillae is arranged radially. It widens the pupil and is driven by the sympathetic system. The light and near reflexes themselves are taught in the physiology chapter. Here the point is simple: a pupil that is too small has usually lost its sympathetic supply, and a pupil that is too large has usually lost its parasympathetic supply or has a damaged or drugged sphincter.

Anisocoria means pupils of unequal size. It is always an efferent (motor) problem. A blind eye does not cause anisocoria, because each pupil receives the same command from both sides of the midbrain. Afferent disease shows up in a different way, as a relative afferent pupillary defect, covered in the last section.

Working up anisocoria: light and dark

The first question is which pupil is the abnormal one. The answer comes from measuring the difference in bright light and again in dim light.

  1. If the difference is greater in the dark, the smaller pupil is failing to dilate. The small pupil is abnormal. Think of Horner syndrome.
  2. If the difference is greater in the light, the larger pupil is failing to constrict. The large pupil is abnormal. Think of a third nerve palsy, an Adie tonic pupil, a dilating drug or a damaged iris.
  3. If the difference is the same in light and dark and both pupils react briskly, this is physiological anisocoria.

Physiological anisocoria is the commonest cause of unequal pupils and is found in up to 20% of people. The difference is 1 mm or less, there is no ptosis, and old photographs often show it has always been there. After this first step, look at the lids and the eye movements, examine the iris on the slit lamp for sphincter tears, adhesions or old inflammation, and then use drops to confirm the diagnosis.

Abnormal pupilAnisocoria greatest inLight reactionConfirming drop
PhysiologicalNeitherEqual in light and darkBriskNone needed
Horner syndromeSmallDarkBrisk, slow to redilateApraclonidine reverses the anisocoria
Third nerve palsyLargeLightPoorConstricts to pilocarpine 1%
Adie tonic pupilLarge (at first)LightPoor, segmentalConstricts to dilute pilocarpine
Pharmacological mydriasisLargeLightAbsentNo constriction to pilocarpine 1%
The main causes of anisocoria

Horner syndrome

Horner syndrome is loss of the sympathetic supply to the eye. The classic triad is a small pupil (miosis), a mild ptosis and reduced sweating (anhidrosis) on the same side. The ptosis is only 1 to 2 mm because the sympathetic system supplies the small smooth muscle of the upper lid (Muller muscle), not the main lid elevator. The lower lid also rises slightly, so the eye can look sunken. The pupil reacts normally to light, but when the lights go down it dilates slowly. This dilation lag is why the anisocoria is most obvious in the first few seconds of darkness.

The pathway has three neurones, and each has its own list of causes.

  1. First order (central): from the hypothalamus down through the brainstem to the spinal cord at C8 to T2, the ciliospinal centre of Budge. Causes are stroke, especially the lateral medullary syndrome, demyelination and cord lesions.
  2. Second order (preganglionic): out of the cord, over the apex of the lung and up the neck to the superior cervical ganglion. Causes are an apical lung (Pancoast) tumour, neck and chest surgery, central line insertion and trauma.
  3. Third order (postganglionic): from the superior cervical ganglion along the internal carotid artery, through the cavernous sinus and into the orbit with the ophthalmic division of the trigeminal nerve. Causes are carotid artery dissection, skull base tumours and cavernous sinus lesions.

Sweating helps to localise. The sweat fibres to most of the face leave the pathway at the superior cervical ganglion, so central and preganglionic lesions cause obvious facial anhidrosis, while postganglionic lesions cause little or none.

Two drops confirm the diagnosis. Cocaine blocks the reuptake of noradrenaline, so it dilates a normal pupil but not a Horner pupil, which has no noradrenaline in the synapse to preserve. The anisocoria therefore increases. Apraclonidine is now used more often because cocaine drops are hard to obtain. It is mainly an alpha-2 agonist with weak alpha-1 action. A denervated dilator muscle becomes supersensitive, so the weak alpha-1 effect dilates the Horner pupil and lifts the lid, while the normal pupil stays the same or constricts a little. The anisocoria reverses. The test can be falsely negative in the first days, before supersensitivity has developed. Hydroxyamphetamine releases stored noradrenaline from an intact third neurone, so a pupil that fails to dilate has a postganglionic lesion. It is rarely available in the UK.

In a child, a Horner syndrome with no history of birth or neck trauma raises the possibility of neuroblastoma, and the child needs examination and imaging with a paediatrician. Congenital Horner syndrome can leave the affected iris paler (heterochromia), because iris pigmentation in infancy depends on sympathetic supply.

The large pupil: third nerve, Adie and drugs

A third nerve palsy gives a large, poorly reactive pupil together with ptosis and limited eye movements. The pupil fibres run on the outside of the nerve, where an aneurysm compresses them first. A dilated pupil with any degree of third nerve palsy is therefore treated as a compressive lesion and imaged urgently. The details are in the lesson on nerve palsies. An isolated dilated pupil with completely normal lids and movements is very rarely a third nerve palsy.

The Adie tonic pupil results from damage to the ciliary ganglion or short ciliary nerves, usually with no cause found. It is most often seen in young women and is unilateral in about 80% of cases. The pupil is large and reacts poorly to light. On the slit lamp, segments of the sphincter are paralysed while others still contract, giving slow worm-like (vermiform) movements of the pupil margin. The near response is better than the light response, but it is slow and sustained, and the pupil redilates slowly afterwards: this is what tonic means. The explanation is misdirected regrowth. Far more fibres in the ciliary ganglion serve accommodation than serve the pupil, so when the nerves regenerate, accommodation fibres end up supplying the sphincter. Over years the tonic pupil tends to become smaller. When tendon reflexes are also lost the condition is called Holmes-Adie syndrome.

The denervated sphincter is supersensitive to acetylcholine-like drugs. Dilute pilocarpine (0.1% or 0.125%) is too weak to affect a normal pupil but constricts a tonic pupil. The test is positive in about 80% of cases and can be negative early on.

Pharmacological mydriasis follows contact with an antimuscarinic drug such as atropine, cyclopentolate, hyoscine patches or certain plants, often by rubbing the eye with a contaminated finger. The pupil is very large and fixed to light and near, with normal lids and movements. Because the receptors are blocked, even full strength pilocarpine 1% fails to constrict it. A pupil dilated by a compressive third nerve palsy does constrict to pilocarpine 1%, because its receptors are intact.

Light-near dissociation and the Argyll Robertson pupil

Light-near dissociation means that the pupils constrict better to a near target than to light. It occurs because the light reflex fibres pass through the dorsal midbrain (the pretectal area) while the fibres for the near response reach the Edinger-Westphal nucleus by a more ventral route, so a lesion can interrupt one and spare the other.

Argyll Robertson pupils are the classic example. They are bilateral, small, irregular pupils that barely react to light but constrict briskly to near, and they dilate poorly in the dark and with mydriatic drops. The traditional cause is neurosyphilis, so syphilis serology is required. Similar pupils are occasionally seen in diabetes and other midbrain disease.

  • Argyll Robertson pupils: small, irregular, brisk near response.
  • Adie tonic pupil: large at first, slow tonic near response.
  • Dorsal midbrain (Parinaud) syndrome: mid-dilated pupils with loss of upgaze.
  • Severe bilateral optic nerve or retinal disease: little light reaches the reflex, but the near response is intact.
  • Aberrant regeneration of the third nerve.

The relative afferent pupillary defect

A relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD), also called a Marcus Gunn pupil, shows that one eye is sending a weaker light signal to the midbrain than the other. It is found with the swinging light test. A bright light is held on one eye for two or three seconds and then moved briskly to the other. Normally both pupils stay the same size. If the second eye has a damaged optic nerve, both pupils dilate when the light arrives on it, because the midbrain now receives less signal than it did a moment before.

  • The pupils are equal in size. An RAPD does not cause anisocoria.
  • Only one working pupil is needed. If one pupil is fixed, watch the other throughout.
  • The usual cause is unilateral or asymmetric optic nerve disease. Extensive retinal disease, such as a central retinal artery occlusion or a large detachment, also produces one.
  • Cataract, vitreous haemorrhage and refractive error do not cause an RAPD, however dense, because scattered light still reaches the retina.
  • Symmetrical bilateral disease gives no RAPD because the test compares one eye with the other.
  • An optic tract lesion gives a mild RAPD in the eye on the opposite side, the eye that has lost its temporal field, because slightly more than half of the fibres cross at the chiasm.

Amblyopia and macular disease cause at most a small RAPD and only when severe. A large defect in an eye with a normal-looking macula points to the optic nerve.

Summary

  • Anisocoria greater in the dark means the small pupil is abnormal; anisocoria greater in the light means the large pupil is abnormal.
  • Physiological anisocoria is 1 mm or less, equal in light and dark, and found in up to 20% of people.
  • Horner syndrome is miosis, mild ptosis and anhidrosis from a lesion in a three-neurone sympathetic pathway.
  • Apraclonidine reverses the anisocoria in Horner syndrome through denervation supersensitivity; cocaine increases it.
  • A painful Horner syndrome is carotid dissection until proved otherwise; in a child think of neuroblastoma.
  • A dilated pupil with ptosis or limited movements is a compressive third nerve palsy until imaging says otherwise.
  • An Adie tonic pupil has segmental sphincter palsy, a slow tonic near response and constricts to dilute pilocarpine (0.1% or 0.125%).
  • A drug-dilated pupil does not constrict even to pilocarpine 1%.
  • Argyll Robertson pupils are small and irregular with light-near dissociation, and need syphilis serology.
  • An RAPD indicates asymmetric optic nerve or extensive retinal disease, never cataract, and does not cause anisocoria.

Check yourself

Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.

1. Anisocoria that is greater in dim light than in bright light suggests which diagnosis?
2. Which drop constricts an Adie tonic pupil but has little effect on a normal pupil?
3. A man has sudden neck pain with a small pupil and slight ptosis on the same side. What is the most important diagnosis to exclude?
4. Which of these does not cause a relative afferent pupillary defect?
Practise 10 questions on this lesson

Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.