Skip to content
Pass Duke Elder
Textbook / Chapter 4 / Cornea, ocular surface and external eye disease

Keratoconus, corneal dystrophies and corneal transplantation

This lesson covers the non-inflammatory diseases of the cornea: keratoconus, in which the cornea thins and bulges, and the inherited dystrophies, each of which belongs to one layer. It then explains the modern corneal graft operations, which replace only the diseased layer, and how graft rejection is recognised.

9 minute read15 linked questions

Keratoconus

An ectasia is a thinning and forward bulging of the cornea. Keratoconus is the commonest: the central or paracentral stroma progressively thins and the cornea steepens into a cone, usually just below the centre. The steep, irregular surface causes myopia and irregular astigmatism, which spectacles cannot fully correct because the surface no longer has two regular principal curves.

It is bilateral but usually asymmetric. It typically starts in the teenage years and progresses into the twenties and thirties, then tends to stabilise. Disease starting in childhood is often more advanced at diagnosis and moves faster.

The strongest associations are eye rubbing and atopy, including vernal keratoconjunctivitis. Others are Down syndrome, connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, Leber congenital amaurosis, obstructive sleep apnoea, floppy eyelid syndrome and a family history.

SignWhat it is
Scissoring reflexA scissor-like movement of the retinoscopy reflex; an early sign
Inferior steepening on topography or tomographyThe earliest objective evidence, with thinning at the steepest point
Vogt striaeFine vertical stress lines in the deep stroma that disappear when the globe is gently pressed
Fleischer ringA brown ring of iron in the epithelium around the base of the cone, best seen with the cobalt blue filter
Munson signThe lower lid bulges into a V shape on downgaze; a late sign
Rizzuti signA torch shone from the temporal side is focused as a sharp cone of light near the nasal limbus
Signs of keratoconus

Acute hydrops is a sudden complication. Descemet's membrane, stretched over the cone, splits, and aqueous floods into the stroma. The cornea becomes white and thick overnight, with pain, watering and a sharp fall in vision. It is managed conservatively with hypertonic saline and a cycloplegic, and settles over weeks to months as endothelial cells cover the gap, leaving a scar.

Managing keratoconus

Treatment has two separate aims: to give useful vision now, and to stop the cone progressing.

  1. Spectacles or soft toric contact lenses in early disease.
  2. Rigid gas permeable contact lenses for most patients. The rigid lens and the tear layer beneath it form a new, regular front surface, neutralising the irregular astigmatism.
  3. Scleral and hybrid lenses when corneal lenses cannot be fitted or tolerated.
  4. Corneal collagen cross-linking when progression is documented.
  5. Intracorneal ring segments in selected lens-intolerant eyes with a clear central cornea.
  6. Corneal transplantation for scarring or when lenses fail: deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty where possible, otherwise penetrating keratoplasty.

Corneal collagen cross-linking (CXL) is the only treatment that addresses progression. The stroma is soaked with riboflavin (vitamin B2) and exposed to ultraviolet A light. The reaction creates extra chemical bonds between collagen fibrils, stiffening the stroma. The aim is to halt the disease, not to reverse it, so it is offered early, while vision is still good. In the standard technique the epithelium is removed first so that riboflavin can enter (epithelium-off).

Corneal dystrophies: one layer each

A corneal dystrophy is an inherited, bilateral, non-inflammatory disease in which abnormal material builds up in one layer of the cornea. Dystrophies are grouped by layer, and for the exam each stromal dystrophy is remembered by three facts: its inheritance, the material deposited and the stain that shows it.

3D atlasThe five layers of the cornea. Each dystrophy, and each type of corneal graft, is defined by the layer involved.
DystrophyLayerInheritanceDeposit and stainKey features
Epithelial basement membrane (map-dot-fingerprint, Cogan)Epithelium and its basement membraneMostly no clear family history; some dominant pedigreesExtra sheets of basement membraneThe commonest. Map lines, dots and fingerprint lines; recurrent erosions
MeesmannEpitheliumAutosomal dominant (keratin genes KRT3, KRT12)Epithelial microcystsRare; fragile epithelium
Reis-BucklersBowman's layerAutosomal dominant (TGFBI)Hyaline-like deposits replacing Bowman's layerPainful erosions from childhood
Granular type 1StromaAutosomal dominant (TGFBI)Hyaline; Masson trichromeDiscrete crumb-like central opacities with clear cornea between; limbus spared
Lattice type 1StromaAutosomal dominant (TGFBI)Amyloid; Congo red, apple-green birefringence in polarised lightFine branching glassy lines; recurrent erosions
Granular type 2 (Avellino)StromaAutosomal dominant (TGFBI)Both hyaline and amyloid; both stainsMixed granular and lattice picture
MacularStroma, reaching Descemet's membrane and endotheliumAutosomal recessive (CHST6)Glycosaminoglycan; Alcian blue or colloidal ironDiffuse haze from limbus to limbus, thin cornea, poor vision early in life
SchnyderStromaAutosomal dominant (UBIAD1)Cholesterol and phospholipid; Oil Red OCentral haze, with crystals in about half
Fuchs endothelialEndothelium and Descemet's membraneAutosomal dominant or sporadic (TCF4 repeat expansion)Guttae on Descemet's membraneCorneal oedema in later life
The main corneal dystrophies

Several of these share one gene. TGFBI, on chromosome 5q31, is mutated in granular, lattice and Reis-Bucklers dystrophy, and different mutations give different deposits. Macular dystrophy stands apart on every count: it is the recessive one, the deposit is glycosaminoglycan because a sulfotransferase enzyme is defective, and it is the most severe, with no clear cornea between the opacities.

Anterior dystrophies cause recurrent corneal erosions, because the epithelium is poorly anchored, and are treated with lubricants, bandage contact lenses or laser removal of the surface (phototherapeutic keratectomy). Stromal dystrophies that reduce vision need a graft, and the dystrophy can recur in the graft because the host cells that lay down the deposit remain.

Fuchs endothelial dystrophy

The corneal stroma is about 78% water and is kept that way by the endothelium, a single layer of cells that pumps fluid out of the stroma into the aqueous. Human endothelial cells do not divide to any useful extent, so losses are made good only by neighbouring cells spreading out. When the cell count falls too low the pump fails and the cornea swells.

In Fuchs endothelial corneal dystrophy endothelial cells are lost prematurely and Descemet's membrane develops guttae, small wart-like excrescences that begin centrally and spread outwards. It classically presents in women in middle age and later. The strongest genetic factor is a trinucleotide repeat expansion in the TCF4 gene; a rare early-onset form is caused by mutations in COL8A2.

The typical symptom is blurred vision on waking that clears during the day. With the lids closed overnight there is no evaporation from the surface, so the cornea swells; once the eyes are open, evaporation draws water out. As the disease advances the blur lasts all day, fluid collects under the epithelium as blisters (bullae), and these rupture painfully.

Specular microscopy shows guttae, a low cell density and cells of varied size and shape. Pachymetry, the measurement of corneal thickness, tracks the oedema. Hypertonic sodium chloride drops or ointment draw water out osmotically and help early disease. Definitive treatment replaces the endothelium by endothelial keratoplasty. Cataract surgery costs endothelial cells and can tip a borderline cornea into permanent oedema, so guttae are looked for before any cataract operation.

Types of corneal transplant

Keratoplasty means corneal transplantation. The modern principle is to replace only the diseased layer and keep the patient's healthy layers, above all their own endothelium if it works.

OperationWhat is replacedTypical indicationPoints to know
Penetrating keratoplasty (PK)All layers, full thicknessDisease of both stroma and endothelium; scars with poor endothelium; perforationMany sutures, slow recovery, marked astigmatism, weak wound, highest rejection risk
Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK)Epithelium and stroma down to Descemet's membraneKeratoconus; stromal scars and dystrophies with healthy endotheliumHost endothelium is kept, so endothelial rejection cannot occur. Air injected into deep stroma (big bubble) separates Descemet's membrane; perforating it may force conversion to PK
Descemet stripping automated endothelial keratoplasty (DSAEK)Descemet's membrane and endothelium, with a thin layer of donor posterior stromaFuchs dystrophy; bullous keratopathy after cataract surgerySmall incision; graft held up by an air bubble while the patient lies on their back
Descemet membrane endothelial keratoplasty (DMEK)Descemet's membrane and endothelium onlyAs for DSAEKThinnest graft: fastest and best visual recovery and lowest rejection rate, but the graft is fragile and more often needs a further air bubble to reattach it
Keratoplasty operations compared

Graft rejection

Corneal grafts do well compared with other transplants and are usually done without tissue matching or systemic immunosuppression. The normal cornea is immune privileged: it has no blood vessels to deliver immune cells and no lymphatics to carry donor antigen to lymph nodes, and its cells express few MHC antigens. Anything that brings vessels into the cornea removes this protection.

Risk factors for rejection are therefore corneal vascularisation, previous graft rejection or repeat grafts, active inflammation, herpetic disease, large grafts and young age. Rejection is an immune attack on a graft that had been clear for at least two weeks. It is distinct from primary graft failure, in which the graft never clears because the donor endothelium was inadequate.

Any layer can be rejected, but endothelial rejection is the commonest and the most serious because lost endothelial cells are not replaced. The patient notices redness, photophobia, pain and falling vision. The signs are keratic precipitates on the graft but not on the host cornea, sometimes arranged in a line that advances across the endothelium (the Khodadoust line), with corneal oedema behind it. Treatment is urgent, intensive topical corticosteroid, hourly at first, with systemic steroid for severe episodes. Caught early, most episodes reverse. The risk falls as less tissue is transplanted: it is highest for PK and lowest for DMEK.

Summary

  • Keratoconus is a bilateral, asymmetric thinning and steepening of the cornea that begins in adolescence and causes irregular astigmatism.
  • It is associated with eye rubbing, atopy, Down syndrome and connective tissue disorders.
  • Signs include scissoring on retinoscopy, Vogt striae, the Fleischer iron ring and Munson sign; acute hydrops follows a split in Descemet's membrane.
  • Rigid contact lenses correct the vision; cross-linking with riboflavin and ultraviolet A halts progression, and NICE supports the epithelium-off technique.
  • Granular dystrophy is hyaline (Masson trichrome), lattice is amyloid (Congo red) and macular is glycosaminoglycan (Alcian blue).
  • Granular and lattice dystrophies are autosomal dominant TGFBI disorders; macular dystrophy is autosomal recessive and the most severe.
  • Fuchs endothelial dystrophy shows guttae on Descemet's membrane and causes corneal oedema with vision worse on waking.
  • DALK replaces the stroma and keeps the host endothelium; DSAEK and DMEK replace the endothelium and keep the host stroma; PK replaces everything.
  • Endothelial rejection shows keratic precipitates on the graft, a Khodadoust line and oedema, and is treated with intensive topical steroid.
  • Corneal vascularisation is the main risk factor for rejection because it ends the cornea's immune privilege.

Check yourself

Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.

1. Which stain demonstrates the deposits of lattice corneal dystrophy?
2. Which stromal dystrophy is inherited in an autosomal recessive pattern?
3. What is the purpose of corneal collagen cross-linking in keratoconus?
4. Which graft is most appropriate for Fuchs endothelial dystrophy with a clear stroma?
Practise 15 questions on this lesson

Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.