Skip to content
Pass Duke Elder
Textbook / Chapter 12 / Orbit, eyelids, lacrimal system and oculoplastics

Eyelid lumps and eyelid tumours

Most eyelid lumps are harmless and many are blocked glands, but the lid is also a common site for skin cancer and one cancer disguises itself as a chalazion. This lesson works through the benign lumps by the structure they arise from, then the malignant tumours, with the features that separate them and the principles of treatment.

10 minute read7 linked questions

The glands of the lid and what blocks them

The lid margin carries three sets of glands, and each produces its own lump. The meibomian glands are large sebaceous glands lying in the tarsal plate, opening behind the lashes. The glands of Zeis are small sebaceous glands attached to the lash follicles. The glands of Moll are apocrine sweat glands, also at the lash line.

A chalazion (meibomian cyst) forms when a meibomian gland blocks. Retained oily secretion leaks into the tarsus and provokes a chronic granulomatous inflammation: the body walls off lipid it cannot clear. The result is a firm, round, painless lump within the lid, away from the margin, which is best seen as a bulge when the lid is everted. It is the commonest lid lump and is commoner in people with blepharitis and rosacea.

A hordeolum (stye) is different in kind: an acute bacterial infection, in effect a small abscess. An external hordeolum is an infected lash follicle and its gland at the lid margin, pointing through the skin around a lash. An internal hordeolum is an infected meibomian gland, pointing on the conjunctival side. Both are painful and tender, which a chalazion is not.

ChalazionHordeolum (stye)
ProcessSterile granulomatous inflammation around retained meibomian secretionAcute bacterial infection of a lid gland or lash follicle
OnsetOver weeksOver days
PainPainless once any early inflammation settlesPainful and tender
SiteIn the tarsal plate, away from the lid marginExternal: lid margin at a lash. Internal: within the tarsus
First treatmentWarm compresses and lid massageWarm compresses; pluck the lash or drain an external stye
If it persistsIncision and curettage, or steroid injectionRefer; topical antibiotic only if there is copious discharge
Chalazion and hordeolum compared

NICE CKS advises warm compresses for 10 to 15 minutes up to five times a day for a chalazion, followed by gentle massage towards the lashes, and no routine antibiotics. Most resolve within weeks to months. If one has not improved after four weeks, referral for incision and curettage can be considered: the lid is everted, the cyst is opened through the conjunctiva with a vertical cut that runs along the gland, and the contents are scraped out. A lesion that has not gone in six months, or keeps returning, should be referred and may be biopsied.

Other benign lumps

  • Cyst of Moll: a blocked apocrine sweat gland at the lid margin. A dome-shaped cyst of clear fluid that lights up when a torch is shone through it.
  • Cyst of Zeis: a blocked sebaceous gland at the lid margin. It contains yellow oily material and does not transilluminate.
  • Epidermoid cyst: a firm, round, keratin-filled cyst arising from a hair follicle, often with a central pore.
  • Squamous papilloma: a skin tag, on a narrow stalk or a broad base. The commonest benign epithelial lid lesion.
  • Seborrhoeic keratosis: a greasy, stuck-on, often pigmented plaque in older people, with no risk of malignant change.
  • Naevus: a benign melanocytic lesion, often at the lid margin with lashes growing through it. Change to melanoma is rare.

Xanthelasma are soft yellow plaques, usually on the medial part of the upper lids and often on both sides. They are collections of lipid-laden (foamy) macrophages in the dermis. They can be linked to raised cholesterol or another lipid disorder, so a lipid profile is worth checking, but many patients have normal lipids. They are removed for appearance only and can recur.

Molluscum contagiosum is a poxvirus infection producing small, shiny, dome-shaped nodules with a central dimple (umbilication). A lesion on the lid margin sheds virus into the tear film and causes a chronic follicular conjunctivitis on that side. The lesion can hide among the lashes, so the lid margin must be searched in any unexplained one-sided follicular conjunctivitis. Removing the lesion cures the conjunctivitis. Histology shows large eosinophilic inclusions in the cytoplasm, the Henderson-Paterson bodies. Lesions can be extensive in people with HIV infection.

Keratoacanthoma is a dome-shaped nodule with a central crater full of keratin that grows over weeks and may regress. It is now regarded as a low-grade squamous cell carcinoma, so it is excised completely.

Recognising a malignant lid lesion

Malignant tumours destroy the structures they grow through, and benign ones push them aside. That principle gives the warning signs.

  • Loss of lashes over the lesion (madarosis).
  • Ulceration, bleeding or crusting that does not heal.
  • Fine dilated vessels on the surface (telangiectasia) and a pearly or irregular border.
  • Destruction or notching of the lid margin, and induration of the surrounding skin.
  • Gradual painless enlargement, particularly with fair skin, heavy sun exposure, previous skin cancer, radiotherapy or immunosuppression.

The examination should include everting the lid and feeling the preauricular, submandibular and cervical lymph nodes. In UK primary care NICE CKS advises referring a suspected malignant eyelid tumour on a suspected cancer pathway. For skin in general, NICE asks for this pathway for suspected squamous cell carcinoma and melanoma, and a routine referral for a suspected BCC unless its site or size makes delay a concern, as it often does on the eyelid.

TumourShare of lid malignanciesTypical siteKey features
Basal cell carcinomaAbout 90%Lower lid, then medial canthusPearly nodule with telangiectasia, may ulcerate; locally invasive, almost never metastasises
Squamous cell carcinomaAbout 5%Lower lidScaly, hyperkeratotic nodule or ulcer; faster growing; perineural and nodal spread
Sebaceous gland carcinomaA few per centUpper lidMimics chalazion or chronic one-sided blepharoconjunctivitis; pagetoid spread
MelanomaUnder 1%Lower lid more oftenChanging pigmented lesion; not all are pigmented
Merkel cell carcinomaRareUpper lidFast-growing painless red-purple nodule in an older person
The malignant eyelid tumours

Basal cell carcinoma

Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) is by far the commonest malignant lid tumour. The cause is ultraviolet damage to fair skin, which explains the preference for the lower lid and medial canthus, where sunlight falls. Other risks are immunosuppression, previous radiotherapy, xeroderma pigmentosum and inherited defects in the PTCH1 gene of the hedgehog signalling pathway, the basis of Gorlin syndrome, in which BCCs appear young and in numbers.

The nodular type is a firm, pearly, raised lesion with fine vessels on its surface. As it outgrows its centre it ulcerates, leaving a crater with a rolled edge, the classical rodent ulcer. The morphoeic (sclerosing) type is a flat, pale, indurated plaque with indistinct edges. Under the microscope it consists of thin strands of tumour in dense fibrous tissue that extend well beyond the visible lesion, so it invades more deeply and is more likely to be incompletely excised. Histology of BCC shows islands of basaloid cells with palisading of the nuclei around the edge of each island.

BCC almost never metastasises. Its danger is local destruction. A neglected tumour at the medial canthus is the most worrying because it can track into the orbit, so eye movements and globe position are checked.

Treatment is complete surgical excision with confirmation that the margins are clear. Mohs micrographic surgery does this in stages on the day: the surgeon removes a thin layer, the whole undersurface and edge are examined microscopically while the patient waits, and further tissue is taken only where tumour remains. This gives the highest cure rate while sparing the most normal tissue, which is why it is favoured for tumours at the medial canthus, morphoeic tumours and recurrences, where lid tissue is precious and the edges are hard to see. Radiotherapy and imiquimod cream are alternatives for selected patients who cannot have surgery. The hedgehog pathway inhibitor vismodegib is licensed for locally advanced and metastatic BCC, but NICE does not recommend it for routine NHS use.

Squamous cell and sebaceous gland carcinoma

Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) is far less common than BCC but more aggressive. It may arise from normal skin or from a precursor: actinic keratosis, a scaly sun-damaged patch, or Bowen's disease, which is carcinoma in situ. It grows faster than a BCC, is more hyperkeratotic and usually lacks the surface vessels. Immunosuppression is a strong risk factor, and SCC is the commonest malignancy after solid organ transplantation. SCC can spread along nerves (perineural invasion, a poor prognostic sign) and to regional lymph nodes. Treatment is excision with margin control, with radiotherapy added for nerve or nodal spread.

Sebaceous gland carcinoma arises from the meibomian glands, the glands of Zeis or the sebaceous glands of the caruncle. It favours the upper lid, which has about twice as many meibomian glands as the lower. It is dangerous because it is so often mistaken for something benign: a chalazion that keeps returning, a yellowish thickening of the lid, or a persistent one-sided blepharoconjunctivitis.

The explanation for the conjunctivitis picture is pagetoid spread: tumour cells travel within the surface epithelium of the conjunctiva and lid, away from the main mass, causing diffuse redness and making the true extent invisible. For that reason the diagnosis needs a full-thickness lid biopsy, and the surgeon takes mapping biopsies from the conjunctiva before excision. Fat stains such as oil red O show lipid in the cells but need fresh frozen tissue, so the pathologist must be told of the suspicion. The tumour metastasises to nodes and has a real mortality. It is also a marker of Muir-Torre syndrome, an autosomal dominant mismatch repair disorder linking sebaceous tumours to bowel, endometrial and urological cancers.

Melanoma and Merkel cell carcinoma

Melanoma of the lid skin is rare. It should be suspected in a pigmented lesion that enlarges, has an irregular border or several colours, or ulcerates and bleeds. Pigment is not a reliable guide in either direction: some melanomas are pale, and BCCs and seborrhoeic keratoses can be pigmented. As elsewhere in the skin, prognosis depends mainly on the depth of invasion. Treatment is wide excision, with sentinel node biopsy for thicker tumours.

Merkel cell carcinoma is a rare neuroendocrine skin cancer of older and immunosuppressed people. About 80% of tumours contain Merkel cell polyomavirus. It presents as a painless, rapidly growing, red-purple nodule, most often on the upper lid near the margin. Immunohistochemistry shows a dot-like pattern of cytokeratin 20 staining. It is highly malignant: many patients already have nodal disease at diagnosis, and mortality is higher than for melanoma. Treatment is excision, sentinel node biopsy and adjuvant radiotherapy.

Summary

  • A chalazion is a painless sterile granuloma around a blocked meibomian gland; a hordeolum is a painful acute infection.
  • Chalazia are treated with warm compresses and massage; persistent ones have incision and curettage through the conjunctiva.
  • A cyst of Moll is clear and transilluminates; a cyst of Zeis is oily and does not.
  • Lid margin molluscum causes a chronic one-sided follicular conjunctivitis that resolves when the lesion is removed.
  • Lash loss, ulceration, telangiectasia and lid margin destruction suggest malignancy.
  • Basal cell carcinoma makes up about 90% of lid malignancies, favours the lower lid and medial canthus, and invades locally without metastasising.
  • Morphoeic and medial canthal BCCs are the most likely to be incompletely excised and are suited to Mohs micrographic surgery.
  • Squamous cell carcinoma arises from actinic keratosis or Bowen's disease and can spread along nerves and to nodes.
  • Sebaceous gland carcinoma favours the upper lid, mimics recurrent chalazion or unilateral blepharoconjunctivitis and shows pagetoid spread.
  • Merkel cell carcinoma is a fast-growing red-purple nodule linked to a polyomavirus, with early nodal spread.

Check yourself

Quick recall on this lesson. These are easier than the question bank.

1. Which is the commonest malignant tumour of the eyelid?
2. A firm painless lump in the upper tarsal plate has been present for two weeks. What is first-line treatment?
3. A child has a chronic follicular conjunctivitis in one eye. Which lid lesion should be looked for?
4. Pagetoid spread within the conjunctival epithelium is characteristic of which tumour?
Practise 7 questions on this lesson

Written for revision. It is not a source of clinical advice, and guidance changes.